Wiktelius S, Edwards C A
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden.
Rev Environ Contam Toxicol. 1997;151:1-37.
Organochlorine insecticides (OCLs), which were introduced in the decade following World War II, were used extensively in Europe, the U.S., and other developed countries into the 1970s. However, data began to accumulate on their persistence in soils and aquatic sediments, their potential to be taken up into animal tissues and to bioconcentrate in birds and mammals in the higher tropic levels of food chains and even in humans. As a result, registration authorities phased out their use progressively, in Europe and the U.S., from 1973 onward. However, the production of OCLs in developed countries and their use in developing countries continued through the 1970s and 1980s into the 1990s because they were, no longer under patent agreement, were inexpensive to manufacture, and were very effective in pest control. In Africa, the use of OCLs continued well into the 1990s for the control of mosquitoes, tsetse flies, and desert locusts as well as to combat various crop, animal, and human pests. Some of these uses involved extensive spraying of large areas of nonagricultural land, thereby exposing many groups and species of wildlife to their residues. Although there is some evidence of a gradual decline in the use of OCLs in Africa, they are still being used in appreciable quantities. During the past 25 yr, there have been 50 published reports of OCL residues in the various groups of invertebrate and vertebrate animals constituting the African fauna. These have been based on a diverse range of surveys, target animals, sampling methods, and analytical techniques. Moreover, they are extremely regionally-biased, the most intense surveys being in Zimbabwe, Kenya, Egypt, and South Africa. DDT was the most commonly used OCL, accounting for about half the total use, followed closely by dieldrin and HCH. Birds and fish have been sampled most intensively, with relatively few studies on other taxa. We reviewed the OCL residue data on African fauna from these reports and summarized the maximum and mean residues in the various groups of terrestrial and aquatic invertebrates and vertebrates. Overall, residues in the fauna were the greatest for DDT, followed in turn by those of dieldrin, HCH, endosulfan, and endrin, with small amounts of aldrin and toxaphene being found in some animals. There were relatively few reports of OCL residues in terrestrial invertebrates and virtually none in aquatic invertebrates. Only a few reports demonstrated OCL residues in terrestrial vertebrates, although high levels of DDT, dieldrin, and HCH were found in crocodile eggs and large residues of dieldrin occurred in bats, squirrels, and monkeys. Considerable OCL residues were reported in a few species of fish, especially Barbus, Clarias, Hydrocynus, Labeo, Sarotherodon, Epiplatys, and Synodontis. These residues were at levels that could have caused chronic toxicity or behavioral changes. The calculated maximum and mean OCL residues in the various elements of the African fauna until 1995 were compared with those calculated for corresponding faunal groups in Europe and the U.S. from their development and introduction up to 1973. The OCL residues reported in African fauna between 1971 and 1975 tended to be significantly higher overall than those published for Europe and the U.S. In particular, residues of DDT and dieldrin in African birds and their eggs were greater than those that had been incriminated as causing significant eggshell thinning and reproductive failure in European and U.S. aquatic and terrestrial birds up to 1973. Additionally, high DDT and dieldrin residues were reported from some species of African fish at levels that could potentially affect their reproduction, have chronic toxic and behavioral effects, and even drastically affect populations. Holistic case studies on the use of OCLs to control tsetse flies and desert locusts were discussed. OCL levels in trophic levels of fauna associated with Lake Kariba (between Zambia and Zimbabwe) were summarized. (AB
有机氯杀虫剂(OCLs)在第二次世界大战后的十年间问世,并在20世纪70年代前在欧洲、美国和其他发达国家广泛使用。然而,关于它们在土壤和水生沉积物中的持久性、进入动物组织并在食物链较高营养级的鸟类和哺乳动物甚至人类体内生物富集的可能性的数据开始积累。结果,从1973年起,欧洲和美国的注册管理机构逐步淘汰了它们的使用。然而,发达国家的OCLs生产及其在发展中国家的使用在20世纪70年代、80年代一直持续到90年代,因为它们不再受专利协议限制,生产成本低廉,且在害虫防治方面非常有效。在非洲,OCLs的使用一直持续到20世纪90年代,用于控制蚊子、采采蝇和沙漠蝗虫,以及对抗各种农作物、动物和人类害虫。其中一些用途涉及对大面积非农业土地的广泛喷洒,从而使许多野生动物群体和物种暴露于其残留之中。尽管有证据表明非洲OCLs的使用在逐渐减少,但它们仍在大量使用。在过去25年里,有50篇关于构成非洲动物群的各种无脊椎动物和脊椎动物群体中OCL残留的报告发表。这些报告基于各种各样的调查、目标动物、采样方法和分析技术。此外,它们存在极大的区域偏差,调查最为密集的地区是津巴布韦、肯尼亚、埃及和南非。滴滴涕(DDT)是最常用的OCL,约占总使用量的一半,其次是狄氏剂和六氯环己烷(HCH)。鸟类和鱼类的采样最为密集,对其他分类群的研究相对较少。我们回顾了这些报告中关于非洲动物群的OCL残留数据,并总结了各种陆生和水生无脊椎动物及脊椎动物群体中的最大残留量和平均残留量。总体而言,动物群中滴滴涕的残留量最大,其次依次是狄氏剂、六氯环己烷、硫丹和异狄氏剂,在一些动物中还发现了少量的艾氏剂和毒杀芬。关于陆生无脊椎动物的OCL残留报告相对较少,而水生无脊椎动物几乎没有相关报告。仅有少数报告表明陆生脊椎动物中有OCL残留,尽管在鳄鱼蛋中发现了高浓度的滴滴涕、狄氏剂和六氯环己烷,并且在蝙蝠、松鼠和猴子体内发现了高浓度的狄氏剂残留。在一些鱼类品种中报告了相当数量的OCL残留,特别是魮属、胡子鲇属、狗脂鲤属、野鲮属、罗非鱼属、灯眼鱼属和歧须鮠属。这些残留量可能已导致慢性毒性或行为变化。将1995年之前非洲动物群各组成部分中计算出的最大和平均OCL残留量与欧洲和美国在其发展和引入至1973年期间相应动物群组中计算出的残留量进行了比较。1971年至1975年间非洲动物群中报告的OCL残留总体上往往显著高于欧洲和美国公布的残留量。特别是,非洲鸟类及其蛋中滴滴涕和狄氏剂的残留量高于1973年之前在欧洲和美国被认为导致水生和陆生鸟类蛋壳显著变薄及繁殖失败的残留量。此外,在一些非洲鱼类品种中报告了高浓度的滴滴涕和狄氏剂残留,其水平可能会影响它们的繁殖,产生慢性毒性和行为影响,甚至对种群数量产生严重影响。讨论了关于使用OCLs控制采采蝇和沙漠蝗虫的综合案例研究。总结了卡里巴湖(赞比亚和津巴布韦之间)相关动物群营养级中的OCL水平。(AB)