McDougall N I, Watson R G, Collins J S, McFarland R J, Love A H
Department of Medicine, Queen's University of Belfast, UK.
Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 1997 Jun;11(3):487-95. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2036.1997.00176.x.
There are few data on the role of prokinetic agents as maintenance therapy in moderately severe reflux oesophagitis despite the high relapse rate of this condition after healing.
To determine whether cisapride is more effective than placebo as maintenance therapy after healing of moderate erosive oesophagitis in two respects: first, in preventing symptomatic relapse and preserving quality of life; and, second, in improving oesophageal motor function.
Forty-two patients whose grade II-III oesophagitis had been healed with omeprazole were randomized to receive either cisapride 20 mg nocte or placebo for 6 months. Oesophageal pH monitoring and manometry were performed before starting maintenance therapy and after 4 weeks, and symptomatic status and quality of life were assessed at weeks 0, 4, 13 and 26.
After 4 weeks of maintenance therapy, lower oesophageal sphincter pressure improved in the cisapride group (16.4-21.9 mmHg, P = 0.01) but not in the placebo group (25.5-22.7 mmHg, P = 0.2). Oesophageal pH monitoring showed no significant changes in either group. Sixteen (76%) cisapride patients and 12 (57%) placebo patients withdrew within 4 weeks owing to symptomatic relapse (P = 0.2). After 26 weeks, 21 (100%) cisapride and 17 (81%) placebo patients had relapsed (log-rank analysis of survival time P = 0.07). Quality of life parameters deteriorated in both treatment groups to a similar degree.
Maintenance therapy with cisapride 20 mg nocte improves the lower oesophageal sphincter pressure in patients whose oesophagitis has been healed with omeprazole. However, cisapride is no better than placebo in preventing symptomatic relapse or deterioration in quality of life.
尽管中度严重反流性食管炎愈合后复发率很高,但关于促动力剂作为维持治疗的作用的数据很少。
确定西沙必利在中度糜烂性食管炎愈合后作为维持治疗在两个方面是否比安慰剂更有效:第一,预防症状复发和维持生活质量;第二,改善食管运动功能。
42例II - III级食管炎用奥美拉唑治愈的患者被随机分为两组,分别接受每晚20mg西沙必利或安慰剂治疗6个月。在开始维持治疗前和4周后进行食管pH监测和测压,并在第0、4、13和26周评估症状状态和生活质量。
维持治疗4周后,西沙必利组食管下括约肌压力改善(16.4 - 21.9 mmHg,P = 0.01),而安慰剂组无改善(25.5 - 22.7 mmHg,P = 0.2)。食管pH监测显示两组均无显著变化。16例(76%)西沙必利组患者和12例(57%)安慰剂组患者因症状复发在4周内退出(P = 0.2)。26周后,21例(100%)西沙必利组和17例(81%)安慰剂组患者复发(生存时间的对数秩分析P = 0.07)。两个治疗组的生活质量参数均有相似程度的恶化。
每晚20mg西沙必利维持治疗可改善用奥美拉唑治愈食管炎患者的食管下括约肌压力。然而,西沙必利在预防症状复发或生活质量恶化方面并不比安慰剂更好。