Fallacaro M D, Wu Y W
Nurse Anesthesia Program, State University of New York at Buffalo, USA.
AANA J. 1997 Jun;65(3):250-6.
A comparative study was conducted examining CRNA feelings of deprivation or resentment as they relate to their job satisfaction. Deprivation is described in Faye Crosby's Theory of Relative Deprivation (1976), which posits that six psychological preconditions (wanting, comparison other, deserving, past expectations, future expectations, and lack of self-blame) have an impact on individual perceptions and can influence job satisfaction. Relative deprivation is defined as a sense of grievance or feeling of resentment that one has been unjustly deprived of some desired thing. It is also sometimes referred to as the discrepancy between one's legitimate expectations and one's actual situation. The three hypotheses examined compare the influence of the six Crosby preconditions of relative deprivation and the three background variables of gender, education, and individual job autonomy on CRNA-felt deprivation. Results from three-way analysis of variance indicated that of the three background variables, only degree of autonomy was found to be significant in explaining felt deprivation. That is, irrespective of gender or educational level, CRNAs reporting higher degrees of job autonomy had lower feelings of deprivation or resentment about their jobs than did individuals reporting limited job autonomy. Degree of autonomy, thus being the key background determinant of CRNA-felt deprivation (F = 14.609, P < .01). Further analysis employing multiple regression revealed that when both the background and the Crosby psychological variables were examined together, the explained variance in deprivation was dramatically increased by the psychological variables far in excess of the background variables. The two psychological variables of wanting and deserving were found as most significant in explaining CRNA felt deprivation. Results indicate the importance of CRNA frustrated wants (wanting) and CRNA perceived entitlements (deserving) as key factors contributing to CRNA job satisfaction above and beyond the three background variables studied.
进行了一项比较研究,考察了麻醉护士与工作满意度相关的被剥夺感或不满情绪。剥夺感在费伊·克罗斯比的相对剥夺理论(1976年)中有描述,该理论认为六个心理前提条件(渴望、比较对象、应得、过去期望、未来期望和缺乏自责)会影响个人认知,并可能影响工作满意度。相对剥夺被定义为一种委屈感或怨恨感,即某人被不公正地剥夺了某种想要的东西。它有时也被称为一个人的合理期望与实际情况之间的差异。所检验的三个假设比较了相对剥夺的六个克罗斯比前提条件以及性别、教育程度和个人工作自主权这三个背景变量对麻醉护士感受到的剥夺感的影响。方差分析的结果表明,在这三个背景变量中,只有自主权程度在解释感受到的剥夺感方面具有显著性。也就是说,无论性别或教育水平如何,报告工作自主权程度较高的麻醉护士对工作的被剥夺感或不满情绪低于报告工作自主权有限的个人。因此,自主权程度是麻醉护士感受到的剥夺感的关键背景决定因素(F = 14.609,P <.01)。进一步采用多元回归分析表明,当同时考察背景变量和克罗斯比心理变量时,心理变量对剥夺感的解释方差显著增加,远远超过背景变量。发现渴望和应得这两个心理变量在解释麻醉护士感受到的剥夺感方面最为显著。结果表明,麻醉护士受挫的渴望(渴望)和麻醉护士感知到的应得权益(应得)作为关键因素,对麻醉护士工作满意度的贡献超过了所研究的三个背景变量。