Borgonha S, Petracchi C, Ferro Luzzi A, Shetty P S, Kurpad A V
St John's National Academy of Health Sciences, Bangalore, India.
Ann Hum Biol. 1997 Jul-Aug;24(4):355-61. doi: 10.1080/03014469700005102.
Total body water (TBW) obtained by deuterium dilution (TBWD) in 45 adult Indian males of low body mass index was compared with values obtained from bioelectrical impedance (TBWImp) and two anthropometry-based prediction equations. Bioelectrical impedance significantly underestimated TBW when compared with deuterium dilution, by 2.75 SD 2.86 kg. Comparisons of the anthropometry-based prediction equations demonstrated that TBW was overestimated by 0.87 SD 2.49 kg, and 2.47 SD 2.57 kg, respectively. Since all parameters in the bioelectrical impedance method were standardized, the difference in the values could have been because of the equation used. Therefore, a fresh equation for the measurement of TBW by the bioelectrical impedance method was derived using the variables of height2/impedance and weight. New prediction equations for TBW were also derived based on anthropometric variables of weight and height. Body weight has the greatest influence in the prediction equations for TBW, and the equation derived was TBW (kg) = 0.533 x body weight (kg) + 3.77, SEE = 2.4 kg. Using height2/impedance gave the relationship: TBW (kg) = 0.568 body weight-0.04 height2/impedance + 4.35, SEE = 1.9 kg.
对45名低体重指数成年印度男性,通过氘稀释法测得的全身水含量(TBW)(TBWD)与通过生物电阻抗法测得的值(TBWImp)以及两个基于人体测量学的预测方程得出的值进行了比较。与氘稀释法相比,生物电阻抗法显著低估了TBW,低估幅度为2.75标准差(2.86千克)。基于人体测量学的预测方程比较结果表明,TBW分别被高估了0.87标准差(2.49千克)和2.47标准差(2.57千克)。由于生物电阻抗法中的所有参数均已标准化,数值差异可能是由于所使用的方程。因此,利用身高²/阻抗和体重变量,推导出了一个通过生物电阻抗法测量TBW的新方程。还基于体重和身高的人体测量学变量推导出了TBW的新预测方程。在TBW的预测方程中,体重的影响最大,得出的方程为TBW(千克)=0.533×体重(千克)+3.77,标准误为2.4千克。利用身高²/阻抗得出的关系为:TBW(千克)=0.568×体重 - 0.04×身高²/阻抗 + 4.35,标准误为1.9千克。