Ransford A O, Hughes S P
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1977 Nov;59-B(4):417-20. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.59B4.925052.
Twenty patients with complete brachial plexus lesions were reviewed approximately nine and a half years after injury. Thirteen were amputees and seven had received no surgical treatment. Amputation did not alleviate pain and a prosthesis was frequently of no greater use of the patient than the useless limb it replaced: only two of the thirteen amputees were true prosthetic users and they both had dominant limb involvement, the rest adapting easily to being one-handed. Initial treatment should therefore be conservative, with intensive rehabilitation and retraining. It is recommended that amputation should not be considered until a year after injury and only if the flail limb causes repulsion, prevents sporting activities or if the patient has difficulty in converting to the non-dominant limb. In no instance should smputation be done for relief of pain.
对20例臂丛神经完全损伤患者在受伤约九年半后进行了复查。其中13例接受了截肢手术,7例未接受手术治疗。截肢并未减轻疼痛,而且假肢对患者的作用通常并不比被其取代的无用肢体更大:13例截肢患者中只有2例是真正使用假肢的,且他们双侧肢体均受累,其余患者很容易适应单手状态。因此,初始治疗应采取保守方法,进行强化康复和再训练。建议在受伤一年后才考虑截肢,而且只有在连枷臂引起排斥反应、妨碍体育活动或者患者难以改用非优势肢体时才考虑。在任何情况下都不应为缓解疼痛而进行截肢。