Druid H
Department of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Health, University Hospital, Linköping, Sweden.
Forensic Sci Int. 1997 Aug 4;88(2):147-62. doi: 10.1016/s0379-0738(97)00104-7.
In a retrospective study, 288 firearm deaths were analysed to identify factors indicating homicide. The cases were classified as suicides (213), homicides (54), accidents (14) and undetermined cases (7). A number of factors, related to the circumstances and the autopsy findings, were studied. Whereas 41% of the homicide victims were females, women only constituted 1.4% of the suicide victims. The mean age was 37 and 50 years among homicide and suicide victims, respectively. Most suicides were committed at or in the vicinity of the residence, whereas a majority of the homicides occurred elsewhere. The majority of the suicide victims had either left a suicide note or had medical records of previous psychiatric illness. In all groups, shotguns were the most frequent weapon used. Fifty-seven percent of the homicide victims, but only three percent of the suicide victims had sustained more than one gunshot wound. One-third of the homicide victims were shot at close range. Alcohol was present in one-third of both homicide and suicide victims. Whereas 38% of the homicidal gunshot wounds had their entrances at anatomical regions typical of suicide, the direction of the bullet path often differed from the directions recorded in suicides. Hence, in this material, an entrance wound in the right temple indicated suicide, but in combination with a direction back-to-front, the wound was more likely to be homicidal. This study suggests that an estimation of the direction of the internal bullet path should be conducted in firearm fatalities, and that this factor may assist in the determination of the manner of death.
在一项回顾性研究中,对288例火器致死案例进行分析以确定表明为他杀的因素。这些案例被分类为自杀(213例)、他杀(54例)、意外(14例)和死因不明案例(7例)。研究了一些与案件情况和尸检结果相关的因素。他杀受害者中41%为女性,而女性仅占自杀受害者的1.4%。他杀和自杀受害者的平均年龄分别为37岁和50岁。大多数自杀发生在住所或住所附近,而大多数他杀发生在其他地方。大多数自杀受害者要么留下了遗书,要么有既往精神疾病的病历。在所有组中,霰弹枪是最常用的武器。57%的他杀受害者,但只有3%的自杀受害者遭受了不止一处枪伤。三分之一的他杀受害者是近距离中枪。三分之一的他杀和自杀受害者体内检测出酒精。虽然38%的他杀枪伤入口位于典型的自杀解剖部位,但子弹路径方向往往与自杀记录的方向不同。因此,在本研究材料中,右颞部的入口伤表明为自杀,但如果结合子弹从后向前的方向,该伤口更可能是他杀所致。本研究表明,对于火器致死案例应评估子弹在体内的路径方向,且该因素可能有助于确定死亡方式。