Evolutionary origins of the reptilian brain: the question of putative homologues of dorsal ventricular ridge. An overview and proposal.

The reptilian brain is characterized by a structure that bulges into the lateral ventricle, called dorsal ventricular ridge (DVR). The DVR was originally considered to be a part of the basal ganglia, although more recent studies indicate that it may correspond to the dorsal part of the hemisphere. The anterior portion of the DVR has several connectional and functional similarities with parts of the mammalian neocortex, for which reason it has been claimed that the two structures can be considered as homologues. In this article I review the evidence supporting and refuting homology of the DVR with different telencephalic structures of mammals, concluding that it is still early to unequivocally ascribe structural correspondences between the different components in the two vertebrate classes. However, a way out of the problem is suggested by comparing the embryonic position of DVR with that of lateral cortex in the reptilian hemisphere. The lateral cortex is considered to be quite comparable in reptiles and mammals, and hence may be a good marker for the original position of the DVR. If the DVR originates dorsal to lateral cortex, it may be considered comparable to parts of the mammalian neocortex, while if it develops in its same position or ventral to it, it may not correspond to the neocortex. Early embryological work indicated that the DVR develops in the same position as the lateral cortex, but arises as a late migration wave, after cells destined to lateral cortex are generated. In other words, instead of being interposed between dorsal and lateral cortices, the DVR may originate in a position overlapping with lateral cortex. If this alternative turns out to be the case, it may imply that the DVR arose de novo, through an extension of the ancestral period of neuroblast proliferation. As a consequence, there may be no structures comparable to it in other vertebrate classes. Finally, it is also proposed that, regardless of whether the DVR and the extrastriate neocortex can or cannot be considered phylogenetic homologues, some of the integrative functions performed by them might have a common evolutionary origin, that became localized in the reptilian DVR and in the mammalian extrastriate neocortex.