Bodis S, Kraus M D, Pinkus G, Silver B, Kadin M E, Canellos G P, Shulman L N, Tarbell N J, Mauch P M
Department of Pathology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 1997 Sep;15(9):3060-6. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1997.15.9.3060.
The patterns of presentation, histologic pattern (nodular or diffuse), treatment, and long-term outcome were studied in patients with lymphocyte-predominant (LP) Hodgkin's disease (HD) to determine whether these patients should be treated differently than patients with other subtypes of HD.
Pathology was reviewed for 97 patients with an initial diagnosis of LPHD made between 1970 and 1993. Seventy-five patients had LPHD on review: 55 had nodular LPHD, 14 had diffuse LPHD, and six had LP histology without subclassification. There were 60 males (80%) and 15 females (20%). Sixty-six patients (88%), presented with clinical stage (CS) I or II disease. Seventy-one patients were treated at the Joint Center for Radiation Therapy (JCRT) and were considered for analysis of treatment outcome. Sixty-one of these 71 were treated with radiation (RT) alone; 17 received mantle RT alone, 27 mantle and paraaortic RT, and seven total-nodal irradiation (TNI). Ten patients with subdiaphragmatic HD received pelvic and paraaortic RT. Of the 10 remaining patients, four were treated with RT and chemotherapy (CT) and six were treated with CT alone. The median follow-up time was 10.8 years.
The 10-year actuarial freedom-from-first-relapse (FFR) and 10-year overall survival rates for the 71 patients with LPHD treated at the JCRT were 80% and 93%, respectively. The 10-year actuarial FFR by nodular (n = 51), diffuse (n = 14), and unspecified (n = 6) histologic pattern was 74%, 100%, and 60%, respectively. Overall, 14 of 71 patients have relapsed: nine of 61 with stage IA, IB, or IIA disease and five of 10 with stage IIB to IVB disease have relapsed. The median time to relapse was 53 months. Nine of 71 patients have died. Only one death has been from HD: five patients died of second cancers, two of cardiac disease, and one of alcoholic liver cirrhosis. Of seven patients with second malignancies, five died. None of the second malignancies were non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL).
Patients with LPHD have different patterns of presentation, sex and age distribution, and likelihood of occult abdominal disease than patients with nodular-sclerosing (NS) or mixed-cellularity (MC) disease. The median time to relapse for LP patients was later than reported for other histologic subtypes; however, there was no pattern of continuous late relapse. With pathologic staging and standard treatment, mortality from LPHD is low; nearly all deaths have been cardiac- or second tumor-related. This suggests that less aggressive treatment for LPHD might continue to yield excellent results, while perhaps lowering the long-term risk of complications.
对淋巴细胞为主型(LP)霍奇金淋巴瘤(HD)患者的临床表现模式、组织学模式(结节状或弥漫性)、治疗方法及长期预后进行研究,以确定这些患者的治疗方式是否应与其他亚型HD患者有所不同。
回顾性分析了1970年至1993年间初诊为LPHD的97例患者的病理资料。复查后确诊为LPHD的患者有75例:55例为结节状LPHD,14例为弥漫性LPHD,6例为未分类的LP组织学类型。男性60例(80%),女性15例(20%)。66例患者(88%)表现为临床I期或II期疾病。71例患者在联合放射治疗中心(JCRT)接受治疗,并纳入治疗结果分析。这71例患者中,61例仅接受放射治疗(RT);17例仅接受斗篷野RT,27例接受斗篷野和主动脉旁RT,7例接受全淋巴结照射(TNI)。10例膈下HD患者接受盆腔和主动脉旁RT。其余10例患者中,4例接受RT和化疗(CT),6例仅接受CT治疗。中位随访时间为10.8年。
在JCRT接受治疗的71例LPHD患者的10年无复发生存率(FFR)和10年总生存率分别为80%和93%。按结节状(n = 51)、弥漫性(n = 14)和未明确分类(n = 6)组织学模式的10年精算FFR分别为74%、100%和60%。总体而言,71例患者中有14例复发:61例IA期、IB期或IIA期疾病患者中有9例复发,10例IIB期至IVB期疾病患者中有5例复发。复发的中位时间为53个月。71例患者中有9例死亡。仅1例死于HD:5例死于第二原发癌,2例死于心脏病,1例死于酒精性肝硬化。7例发生第二原发恶性肿瘤的患者中,5例死亡。第二原发恶性肿瘤均非非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)。
与结节硬化型(NS)或混合细胞型(MC)HD患者相比,LPHD患者的临床表现模式、性别和年龄分布以及隐匿性腹部疾病的可能性均有所不同。LP患者复发的中位时间晚于其他组织学亚型报道的时间;然而,不存在持续的晚期复发模式。通过病理分期和标准治疗,LPHD的死亡率较低;几乎所有死亡均与心脏疾病或第二肿瘤相关。这表明对LPHD采用不太积极的治疗可能仍会取得优异的结果,同时或许能降低长期并发症风险。