Breen N, Feuer E J, Depuy S, Zapka J
Applied Research Branch, NCI/NIH, Bethesda MD 20892-7344, USA.
Public Health Rep. 1997 Sep-Oct;112(5):423-32.
In January 1991, Medicare extended its mammography benefit to reimburse for breast cancer screening mammograms. In 1991 and again in 1993, the National Cancer Institute Breast Cancer Screening Consortium (BCSC) conducted a survey to test the hypothesis that this benefit would increase mammography use among women over the age of 65.
The authors analyzed data on non-Hispanic white women ages 65 to 74 living in 11 geographic areas targeted by the BCSC for an earlier study--six that had received cancer screening educational interventions and five control subsites--to measure the impact of the newly adopted Medicare benefit on the use of mammography and use of Medicare to reimburse mammography costs.
The data show little overall increase between 1991 and 1993 in reported mammography use among respondents to the survey. However, in six intervention and five control subsites there was an increase in the percentage of women who reported using public payment sources to at least partially reimburse the cost of mammograms. In three intervention subsites, the increase from 1991 to 1993 in the percentage of women using public sources of payment was greater than in the corresponding control subsites.
These findings suggest that public health interventions are more likely to succeed when educational promotion accompanies a financial benefit.
1991年1月,医疗保险扩大了其乳房X光检查福利,以报销乳腺癌筛查乳房X光检查费用。1991年和1993年,美国国家癌症研究所乳腺癌筛查联盟(BCSC)进行了一项调查,以检验这一福利会增加65岁以上女性乳房X光检查使用率这一假设。
作者分析了居住在BCSC早期研究选定的11个地理区域的65至74岁非西班牙裔白人女性的数据——6个接受了癌症筛查教育干预的地区和5个对照子站点——以衡量新采用的医疗保险福利对乳房X光检查使用情况以及医疗保险报销乳房X光检查费用情况的影响。
数据显示,1991年至1993年期间,接受调查的受访者报告的乳房X光检查使用率总体上几乎没有增加。然而,在6个干预地区和5个对照子站点,报告使用公共支付来源至少部分报销乳房X光检查费用的女性比例有所增加。在3个干预子站点,1991年至1993年期间使用公共支付来源的女性比例的增幅大于相应的对照子站点。
这些发现表明,当教育推广伴随着经济福利时,公共卫生干预更有可能取得成功。