Charlton M R, Kondo M, Roberts S K, Steers J L, Krom R A, Wiesner R H
Liver Transplantation Unit, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
Liver Transpl Surg. 1997 Jul;3(4):359-64. doi: 10.1002/lt.500030402.
End-stage liver disease secondary to cryptogenic cirrhosis is the indication for orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) in 7% to 14% of recipients. However, there are no reports documenting the outcome of OLT for this indication. The aim of this study was to determine (1) survival and (2) the incidence of histological recurrence of cryptogenic cirrhosis after OLT. Between March 1985 and December 1994, 560 OLTs were performed at our institution. Of these, 39 transplants for cryptogenic cirrhosis were in patients who met the following criteria: antinuclear antibody < 1:40; negative anti-smooth muscle antibody, antimitochondrial antibody, polymerase chain reaction for hepatitis C virus, and hepatitis B surface antigen results; normal ceruloplasmin and alpha-1 antitrypsin phenotype; transferrin saturation < 65%; and liver biopsy specimen not suggestive of hemochromatosis or other known disorders. Histological recurrence was assessed with protocol liver biopsies in all patients who survived longer than 6 months. The mean age of cryptogenic recipients at the time of transplantation was significantly lower (40.6 years; range, 3 to 63 years) than that of noncryptogenic recipients (48.5 years; range, 1-70; P < .03). Median modified Child's-Pugh score was slightly higher for cryptogenic recipients at the time of transplantation (10.0 + 0.08 standard error of mean [SEM]), than for the noncryptogenic recipients (9.0 + 0.03 SEM; P < .02). Actuarial survival was 72% (+ 0.07 SEM) at 1 and 58% (+ 0.08 SEM) at 5 years for cryptogenic recipients compared with 89% at 1 and 80% at 5 years for noncryptogenic recipients. The difference in survival was significant (P < .001) at both 1 and 5 years. Among the 27 cryptogenic recipients surviving more than 6 months (mean follow-up, 5.5 years), 6 have persistent hepatitis histologically without apparent infectious, vascular, biliary, or drug origins. Four patients (15%) had chronic active hepatitis, and 2 (7%) had steatohepatitis. No cases of recurrent cryptogenic cirrhosis were seen. OLT for cryptogenic cirrhosis is associated with a poor outcome compared with other indications, hepatitis of uncertain origin occurred in 22% of cryptogenic recipients surviving longer than 6 months, and no evidence of recurrence of cryptogenic cirrhosis was seen thus far in follow-up.
隐源性肝硬化所致终末期肝病是7%至14%的原位肝移植(OLT)受者的移植指征。然而,尚无关于该指征OLT结局的报道。本研究的目的是确定(1)OLT后的生存率和(2)隐源性肝硬化组织学复发的发生率。1985年3月至1994年12月期间,我们机构共进行了560例OLT。其中,39例因隐源性肝硬化接受移植的患者符合以下标准:抗核抗体<1:40;抗平滑肌抗体、抗线粒体抗体、丙型肝炎病毒聚合酶链反应及乙肝表面抗原结果均为阴性;铜蓝蛋白和α-1抗胰蛋白酶表型正常;转铁蛋白饱和度<65%;肝活检标本未提示血色素沉着症或其他已知疾病。对所有存活超过6个月的患者,通过定期肝活检评估组织学复发情况。隐源性肝硬化受者移植时的平均年龄(40.6岁;范围3至63岁)显著低于非隐源性肝硬化受者(48.5岁;范围1至70岁;P<.03)。隐源性肝硬化受者移植时改良Child-Pugh评分中位数(10.0+0.08平均标准误[SEM])略高于非隐源性肝硬化受者(9.0+0.03 SEM;P<.02)。隐源性肝硬化受者1年时的精算生存率为72%(+0.07 SEM),5年时为58%(+0.08 SEM),而非隐源性肝硬化受者1年时为89%,5年时为80%。1年和5年时生存率的差异均有统计学意义(P<.OO1)。在27例存活超过6个月的隐源性肝硬化受者中(平均随访5.5年),6例组织学上有持续性肝炎,无明显感染、血管、胆管或药物来源。4例患者(15%)有慢性活动性肝炎,2例(7%)有脂肪性肝炎。未见复发性隐源性肝硬化病例。与其他指征相比,隐源性肝硬化OLT的结局较差,在存活超过6个月的隐源性肝硬化受者中,22%发生了病因不明的肝炎病例,随访至今未见隐源性肝硬化复发的证据。