Different healing rates of bone autografts, syngeneic grafts, and allografts in an experimental rat model.

Matching of donors and recipients for tissue antigens is vitally important for successful transplantation of essentially all organs and tissues, the major exception being bone. The importance of tissue-typing for the healing of bone allografts remains, however, a controversial issue as development of both humoral and cell-mediated immunity against the grafted bone has been observed in some experimental systems. In the present study, we compared the healing patterns of frozen antigen-mismatched allografts, frozen antigen-matched allografts (syngeneic grafts), and fresh cortical bone autografts in an experimental rat model. Histomorphometry of the graft-host interface revealed that new bone formation started significantly earlier in autografts than in allografts or syngeneic grafts. By 2 weeks, the level of new bone formation in the syngeneic grafts had reached that in autografts. Antigen-mismatched allografts, however, continued to exhibit a retarded formation of new bone throughout the union process. These histomorphometric observations were confirmed by molecular biologic analyses for the mRNA levels of type I collagen, which increased earlier and reached a higher level in autografts than in allografts. Use of syngeneic grafts resulted in a longer persistence of type I collagen mRNA expression in the healing tissue than in antigen-mismatched allografts. No apparent differences were seen between allografts and autografts in the expression of type III collagen. No cartilage-specific type II collagen mRNA was observed, indicating that antigen-mismatching or preservation by freezing did not alter the basic mechanism of the interface healing process, although it did slow down the beginning of the process. The experiments suggest that a major antigen mismatch between donor and recipient affects the temporal gene expression of extracellular bone matrix and delays new bone formation at the graft-host interface of cortical bone allografts.