Sclavo M, Aruta E, Presbitero P
Divisione di Cardiologia, Ospedale Giovanni Bosco, Torino.
G Ital Cardiol. 1997 Oct;27(10):1000-7.
Echocardiographically recognized resting function, myocardial viability (by low-dose dobutamine) and stress-induced ischemia (by high-dose dipyridamole) are potent predictors of subsequent events, but their relative value in patients evaluated very early after acute myocardial infarction remains to be established.
To assess the feasibility and usefulness of an integrated approach with resting and pharmacological stress echo for risk stratification in patients evaluated very early after myocardial infarction.
Sixty acute myocardial infarction patients without contraindications to stress testing, and who were being given thrombolytic therapy, underwent resting echo (16-segment model of left ventricle, each segment scored from 1 = normo-hyperkinetic to 4 = dyskinetic), high-dose dipyridamole (up to 0.84 mg/kg over 10') and low-dose dobutamine (up to 10 mcg/kg/min) echo on the third-fourth day after drug withdrawal. The response was "ischemic" with a dipyridamole-induced increase in the regional score > 1 in segments with a resting score < 3, and "viable" with a dobutamine-induced decrease in the regional score > 1 in segments with resting score > 1. All patients underwent coronary angiography on the tenth-twelfth day after the acute event, and all of them were followed up for 15 +/- 10.04 months.
Ischemia elicited by dipyridamole appeared in 29 patients (48%) and dobutamine-induced viability was observed in 28 (47%). Ischemic events occurred in 26 patients (43.4%), five of which during the early in-hospital period. There were three deaths (5%), one re-AMI (1.7%), 7 Canadian Class III-IV angina (12%) and 15 (25%) early revascularization procedures undertaken independently of stress echo results. Events occurred in 21 patients (72%) with dipyridamole-induced ischemia and in 5 (16%) without it (p < 0.001). Likewise, events occurred in 13 patients (46.4%) with dobutamine-induced inotropic recovery and in 13 (40.6%) without it (p = ns). Event-free survival occurred in 64% of dipyridamole-positive patients, as opposed to 90% of dipyridamole-negative patients (p = 0.025). Dipyridamole echocardiographic test sensitivity and specificity for events were 81 and 74%, respectively. Sensitivity and specificity for events of dobutamine viability were 46 and 55%, respectively. In a multivariate logistic analysis, dipyridamole-induced myocardial ischemia was the strongest predictor of subsequent events (p = 0.01). According to Cox analysis, dipyridamole positivity had a relative risk estimate of 4.
Pharmacological stress echo is feasible even very early after acute myocardial infarction via a useful approach based on low-dose dobutamine to assess myocardial viability, and high-dose dipyridamole to assess ischemia. For risk stratification purposes, stress-induced myocardial ischemia outperforms resting function and myocardial viability, and it is independent of angiographic data. Revascularization procedures do not seem to be effective when only viability is present.
超声心动图识别的静息功能、心肌存活(通过小剂量多巴酚丁胺)和应激诱导的缺血(通过大剂量双嘧达莫)是后续事件的有力预测指标,但它们在急性心肌梗死后极早期评估的患者中的相对价值仍有待确定。
评估在心肌梗死后极早期评估的患者中,采用静息和药物负荷超声心动图综合方法进行危险分层的可行性和实用性。
60例无负荷试验禁忌证且正在接受溶栓治疗的急性心肌梗死患者,在停药后第3至4天接受静息超声心动图检查(左心室16节段模型,每个节段从1分=正常-运动亢进到4分=运动障碍进行评分)、大剂量双嘧达莫(10分钟内达0.84mg/kg)和小剂量多巴酚丁胺(达10mcg/kg/min)超声心动图检查。双嘧达莫诱导静息评分<3的节段区域评分增加>1为“缺血”反应,多巴酚丁胺诱导静息评分>1的节段区域评分降低>1为“存活”反应。所有患者在急性事件后第10至12天接受冠状动脉造影,并全部随访15±10.04个月。
29例患者(48%)出现双嘧达莫诱发的缺血,28例(47%)观察到多巴酚丁胺诱导的存活。26例患者(43.4%)发生缺血事件,其中5例发生在住院早期。有3例死亡(5%),1例再发急性心肌梗死(1.7%),7例加拿大心血管学会III-IV级心绞痛(12%),15例(25%)早期血运重建手术,其进行与负荷超声心动图结果无关。双嘧达莫诱发缺血的21例患者(72%)发生事件,无缺血的5例患者(16%)发生事件(p<0.001)。同样,多巴酚丁胺诱导心肌收缩恢复的13例患者(46.4%)发生事件,无恢复的13例患者(40.6%)发生事件(p=无显著性差异)。双嘧达莫阳性患者的无事件生存率为64%,而双嘧达莫阴性患者为90%(p=0.025)。双嘧达莫超声心动图试验对事件的敏感性和特异性分别为81%和74%。多巴酚丁胺存活对事件的敏感性和特异性分别为46%和55%。在多因素逻辑分析中,双嘧达莫诱发的心肌缺血是后续事件的最强预测指标(p=0.01)。根据Cox分析,双嘧达莫阳性的相对风险估计值为4。
通过基于小剂量多巴酚丁胺评估心肌存活和大剂量双嘧达莫评估缺血的有用方法,药物负荷超声心动图在急性心肌梗死后极早期也是可行的。为进行危险分层,应激诱导的心肌缺血优于静息功能和心肌存活,且独立于血管造影数据。仅存在存活心肌时,血运重建手术似乎无效。