Saito Y, Kita Y, Bando M, Nagura H, Yamanouchi H, Ishii K
Department of Neurology, Tokyo Metropolitan Geriatric Hospital.
Rinsho Shinkeigaku. 1997 Jun;37(6):487-91.
It remains controversial whether agraphia can coexist in a case with apraxia of speech, and whether an apraxia of speech can be classified into a category of aphasia. We examined the presence of agraphia in 2 right-handed patients of apraxia of speech. Case 1 of mild agraphia showed an infarcted lesion in the left precentral gyrus extending to the neighboring white matter, which involving the arcuate fasciculus on MRI. Positron emission tomography (PET) indicated decrease of cerebral blood flow (CBF) and cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen (CMRO2) in the infarcted lesion, but no decrease of CBF and CMRO2 in the Broca's area. In this case, agraphia was more conspicuous in "kanji" than in "kana" and severity of the agraphia was not correlated to that of speech disturbance on naming test. Case 2 without agraphia showed a small infarcted lesion in the left precentral gyrus, which did not extend to the deep white matter on MRI. Agraphia can coexist with apraxia of speech in a case with the lesion in the left precentral gyrus, in which the cortical lesion is relatively widespread or extends to the deep white matter. However, lack of etiological connection between the agraphia and the apraxia of speech was suggested. We could not confirm the location in the left precentral gyrus which is responsible for the agraphia.
失写症是否能与言语失用症并存,以及言语失用症是否可归类为失语症的一种,目前仍存在争议。我们检查了2例右利手言语失用症患者的失写症情况。病例1有轻度失写症,其左侧中央前回有梗死性病变并延伸至邻近白质,MRI显示该病变累及弓状束。正电子发射断层扫描(PET)显示梗死性病变处脑血流量(CBF)和脑氧代谢率(CMRO2)降低,但布洛卡区的CBF和CMRO2未降低。在该病例中,失写症在书写汉字时比书写假名时更明显,且失写症的严重程度与命名测试中的言语障碍严重程度无关。病例2无失写症,其左侧中央前回有一个小的梗死性病变,MRI显示该病变未延伸至深部白质。在左侧中央前回有病变,且皮质病变相对广泛或延伸至深部白质的情况下,失写症可与言语失用症并存。然而,提示失写症与言语失用症之间缺乏病因学联系。我们无法确定左侧中央前回中导致失写症的部位。