Frisell J, Lidbrink E, Hellström L, Rutqvist L E
Department of Surgery, Södersjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden.
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 1997 Sep;45(3):263-70. doi: 10.1023/a:1005872617944.
Results from several randomised mammography screening trials have shown that it is possible to reduce mortality in breast cancer by mammographic screening at least for women above 50 years of age. The purpose of this article is to present data on mortality in breast cancer in study and control groups of the Stockholm trial after 11 years of followup, to analyse which age group benefits most from screening. In March 1981, 40,318 women in Stockholm, aged 40 through 64 years, entered a randomized trial of breast cancer screening by single view mammography alone, versus no intervention in a control group of 20,000 women. Two screening rounds were performed and the attendance rate was over 80% in the two rounds. During 1986 the control group was invited once to screening. Totally 428 and 217 cases of breast cancer were diagnosed in the study and control groups respectively. After a mean follow-up of 11.4 years a nonsignificant mortality reduction of 26% was observed for the whole study group, with a relative risk (RR) of death in breast cancer of 0.74 (CI(confidence interval) = 0.5-1.1). For women aged 50-64 years a significant 38% mortality reduction was observed with a RR of 0.62 (CI = 0.38-1.0). For women aged 40-49 years no effect on mortality was found, with a RR of death in breast cancer of 1.08 (CI = 0.54-2.17). The breakpoint for benefit in this study seemed to be at 50 years of age when 5-year age groups were analysed, but this tendency is uncertain because of the low statistical power in the analysis of the younger age groups. Long screening intervals, the use of single-view mammography, and the fact that more than 50% of the women in age group 40-49 years were still below 50 years of age when the study was closed, were all facts that could have influenced the results in age group 40-49 years. Larger studies are needed to answer the question whether mammographic screening can be successful in younger age groups.
多项随机乳房X线筛查试验的结果表明,至少对于50岁以上的女性,通过乳房X线筛查有可能降低乳腺癌死亡率。本文的目的是呈现斯德哥尔摩试验研究组和对照组在随访11年后乳腺癌死亡率的数据,分析哪个年龄组从筛查中获益最大。1981年3月,斯德哥尔摩的40318名年龄在40至64岁的女性进入了一项仅通过单视图乳房X线进行乳腺癌筛查的随机试验,而20000名女性的对照组不进行干预。进行了两轮筛查,两轮的参与率均超过80%。1986年,对照组被邀请进行了一次筛查。研究组和对照组分别诊断出428例和217例乳腺癌病例。在平均随访11.4年后,整个研究组观察到死亡率非显著降低26%,乳腺癌死亡的相对风险(RR)为0.74(置信区间(CI)=0.5 - 1.1)。对于50至64岁的女性,观察到死亡率显著降低38%,RR为0.62(CI = 0.38 - 1.0)。对于40至49岁的女性,未发现对死亡率有影响,乳腺癌死亡的RR为1.08(CI = 0.54 - 2.17)。当按5岁年龄组进行分析时,本研究中的获益转折点似乎在50岁,但由于对较年轻年龄组分析的统计效力较低,这种趋势并不确定。筛查间隔时间长、使用单视图乳房X线以及在研究结束时40至49岁年龄组中超过50%的女性仍未满50岁,这些都是可能影响40至49岁年龄组结果的因素。需要更大规模的研究来回答乳房X线筛查在较年轻年龄组是否能成功的问题。