Whitten T M, Wallace T W, Bird R E, Turk P S
Department of General Surgery, Carolinas Medical Center, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA.
Am Surg. 1997 Dec;63(12):1072-7; discussion 1077-8.
Image-guided core biopsy (IGCB) of nonpalpable mammographic abnormalities has gained attention as an alternative to needle-localized breast biopsy (NLB). This study evaluated IGCB in the diagnostic workup of patients with nonpalpable mammographic lesions suspicious for cancer. Eighty-six patients who underwent IGCB were compared to 85 patients who underwent NLB for the diagnosis of mammographic lesions suspicious for cancer. The incidence of positive margins was less in patients who subsequently underwent needle-localized resection in the IGCB group than in the NLB group (29 and 65%; P < 0.0001). The volume of excision was greater for patients in the IGCB group than for the NLB group (106 cm3 and 52 cm3; P < 0.0001). Patients in the IGCB group averaged 1.1 operative procedures compared with patients in the NLB group, who required an average of 1.9 operative procedures. The mean charge for an IGCB was $1011 compared to $2975 for a NLB. Subset analysis of 32 spiculated masses from the IGCB group and 21 from the NLB group showed similar advantages of IGCB over NLB. The preoperative use of IGCB for mammographically suspicious lesions can reduce the incidence of positive surgical margins and the number of surgical procedures required. The use of IGCB allows for a more efficient diagnostic workup and less expense to the patient.
影像引导下的乳腺不可触及病变粗针活检(IGCB)作为针定位乳腺活检(NLB)的替代方法已受到关注。本研究评估了IGCB在对乳腺钼靶检查发现的可疑癌性病变患者进行诊断性检查中的应用。将86例行IGCB的患者与85例行NLB以诊断乳腺钼靶检查发现的可疑癌性病变的患者进行比较。IGCB组随后接受针定位切除的患者切缘阳性发生率低于NLB组(分别为29%和65%;P<0.0001)。IGCB组患者的切除体积大于NLB组(分别为106 cm³和52 cm³;P<0.0001)。IGCB组患者平均接受1.1次手术,而NLB组患者平均需要接受1.9次手术。IGCB的平均费用为1011美元,而NLB为2975美元。对IGCB组的32个毛刺状肿块和NLB组的21个毛刺状肿块进行的亚组分析显示,IGCB相对于NLB具有类似的优势。术前对乳腺钼靶检查可疑病变使用IGCB可降低手术切缘阳性的发生率以及所需的手术次数。使用IGCB可实现更高效的诊断性检查,并减少患者的费用。