Johnson E M, Canafax D M, Gillingham K J, Humar A, Pandian K, Kerr S R, Najarian J S, Matas A J
University of Minnesota, Department of Surgery, Minneapolis, USA.
Clin Transplant. 1997 Dec;11(6):552-7.
Acute rejection is the greatest risk factor for development of biopsy-proven chronic rejection and late kidney allograft loss. We previously noted that low cyclosporine (CsA) levels were a risk factor for early acute rejection in pediatric recipients (1). In our current study, we used logistic regression to identify risk factors for acute rejection in 726 adult kidney transplant recipients on triple therapy (prednisone, azathioprine, CsA). Variables considered for logistic regression analysis were donor organ source (cadaver vs. living), degree of HLA mismatch (1 to 6 vs. 0 antigen mismatch), transplant number (primary vs. retransplant), CsA levels (< 125 vs. > or = 125 ng/ml, < 150 ng/ml vs. > or = 150 ng/ml, and < 175 vs. > or = 175 ng/ml), and acute rejection episodes (0 vs. > or = 1). Of 726 recipients, 401 (55%) received cadaver kidneys; 325 (45%), living related. Overall, 572 (79%) had a primary transplant; 154 (21%), a retransplant. The vast majority of acute rejection episodes occurred within the first 2 months posttransplant; 68% of recipients had no acute rejection episodes by 2 months and 58% had none by 60 months posttransplant. Logistic regression analysis revealed that a cadaver donor kidney (vs. living) (p = 0.004), a 1 to 6 antigen mismatch (vs. 0 mismatch) (p = 0.001), and CsA levels < 150 ng/ml (vs. > or = 150 ng/ml) correlated with biopsy-proven acute rejection. The correlation for CsA levels < 150 ng/ml (vs. > or = 150 ng/ml) held true for levels at 1 wk (p < 0.05), 1 month (p = 0.0001), 2 months (p = 0.01), and 3 months (p = 0.02) posttransplant. Similar correlation was found for CsA levels < 125 ng/ml (vs. > or = 125 ng/ml) and < 175 ng/ml (vs. > or = 175 ng/ml). Comparative analyses were made (by Chi-square) of acute and chronic rejection rates when recipients were divided into 3 groups by CsA level (< 125 ng/ml, > or = 125 to < 150 ng/ml, and > or 150 ng/ml). At each time point (1 wk, 2 wk, 1 month, 2 months, 3 months), CsA levels < 125 ng/ml (vs. > or = 125 to < 150 ng/ml and > or = 150 ng/ml) were associated with the greatest increased risk of acute rejection--for both cadaver and living related recipients (all p < 0.05). CsA levels < 125 ng/ml at each time point (1 wk, 2 wk, 1 month, 2 months, 3 months) were also associated with a significantly increased risk of chronic rejection (all p < 0.001). The incidence of both acute and chronic rejection was reduced in the group with CsA levels > or = 125 to < 150 ng/ml and further reduced in the > or = 150 ng/ml group. Our data indicate that maintaining CsA levels > or = 150 ng/ml as part of triple therapy reduces the incidence of both acute and chronic rejection. Because chronic rejection is the leading cause of late allograft loss, maintaining adequate CsA levels should improve long-term graft survival. Based on this analysis, we have modified our own immunosuppressive regimens to achieve higher CsA levels earlier posttransplant.
急性排斥反应是经活检证实的慢性排斥反应和晚期肾移植失败发生的最大风险因素。我们之前注意到,低环孢素(CsA)水平是小儿肾移植受者早期急性排斥反应的一个风险因素(1)。在我们目前的研究中,我们使用逻辑回归分析来确定接受三联疗法(泼尼松、硫唑嘌呤、CsA)的726例成年肾移植受者发生急性排斥反应的风险因素。逻辑回归分析所考虑的变量包括供体器官来源(尸体供肾与活体供肾)、HLA错配程度(1至6个抗原错配与0个抗原错配)、移植次数(初次移植与再次移植)、CsA水平(<125 ng/ml与≥125 ng/ml、<150 ng/ml与≥150 ng/ml、<175 ng/ml与≥175 ng/ml)以及急性排斥反应发作情况(0次与≥1次)。在726例受者中,401例(55%)接受尸体供肾;325例(45%)接受活体亲属供肾。总体而言,572例(79%)为初次移植;154例(21%)为再次移植。绝大多数急性排斥反应发作发生在移植后的前2个月内;68%的受者在移植后2个月时未发生急性排斥反应发作,58%的受者在移植后60个月时未发生。逻辑回归分析显示,尸体供肾(与活体供肾相比)(p = 0.004)、1至6个抗原错配(与0个错配相比)(p = 0.001)以及CsA水平<150 ng/ml(与≥150 ng/ml相比)与经活检证实的急性排斥反应相关。CsA水平<150 ng/ml(与≥150 ng/ml相比)在移植后1周(p < 0.05)、1个月(p = 0.0001)、2个月(p = 0.01)和3个月(p = 0.02)时均存在相关性。CsA水平<125 ng/ml(与≥125 ng/ml相比)和<175 ng/ml(与≥175 ng/ml相比)也发现了类似的相关性。当根据CsA水平(<125 ng/ml、≥125至<150 ng/ml以及≥150 ng/ml)将受者分为3组时,对急性和慢性排斥反应发生率进行了(通过卡方检验)比较分析。在每个时间点(1周、2周、1个月、2个月、3个月),CsA水平<125 ng/ml(与≥125至<150 ng/ml以及≥150 ng/ml相比)与急性排斥反应风险的最大增加相关——对于尸体供肾和活体亲属供肾受者均如此(所有p < 0.05)。在每个时间点(1周、2周、1个月、2个月、3个月),CsA水平<125 ng/ml也与慢性排斥反应风险的显著增加相关(所有p < 0.001)。CsA水平≥125至<150 ng/ml组的急性和慢性排斥反应发生率均降低,而≥150 ng/ml组的发生率进一步降低。我们的数据表明,作为三联疗法的一部分,将CsA水平维持在≥150 ng/ml可降低急性和慢性排斥反应的发生率。由于慢性排斥反应是晚期移植失败的主要原因,维持足够的CsA水平应可改善长期移植物存活。基于此分析,我们已修改了自己的免疫抑制方案,以便在移植后更早地达到更高的CsA水平。