Thomas D W, Ryde S J, Ali P A, Birks J L, Evans C J, Saunders N H, Al-Zeibak S, Dutton J, Hancock D A
Department of Medical Physics and Clinical Engineering, Singleton Hospital, Swansea NHS Trust, UK.
Physiol Meas. 1997 Nov;18(4):305-15. doi: 10.1088/0967-3334/18/4/004.
Infra-red interactance has been evaluated as a technique for measuring total body fat in comparison with a range of alternative methods. The alternative techniques employed were neutron activation analysis, tritiated water dilution, whole-body potassium-40 counting, skinfold anthropometry, bioelectrical impedance analysis and the body mass index. The study group consisted of 43 healthy adults (16 males and 27 females). For 11 women, measurements were obtained before and after 11 weeks on a very low-calorie diet, giving a total of 54 sets of data. Correlation coefficients between infra-red interactance and the other techniques varied between 0.58 (p < 0.0002) and 0.80 (p < 0.0001) for females, and between 0.64 (p < 0.009) and 0.94 (p < 0.0001) for males. The average fat for the study group was underestimated by 15% using infra-red interactance in comparison with the average fat obtained from the other techniques. It was also noted that the infra-red interactance instrument yielded a very narrow range of body fats in females in comparison with the other techniques. It is essential that these differences are reconciled before infra-red interactance takes a significant role in body composition analysis.
与一系列其他方法相比,红外交互作用已被评估为一种测量全身脂肪的技术。所采用的其他技术包括中子活化分析、氚水稀释法、全身钾-40计数、皮褶厚度人体测量法、生物电阻抗分析和体重指数。研究组由43名健康成年人(16名男性和27名女性)组成。对于11名女性,在进行11周极低热量饮食前后进行了测量,共获得54组数据。女性中,红外交互作用与其他技术之间的相关系数在0.58(p<0.0002)至0.80(p<0.0001)之间,男性则在0.64(p<0.009)至0.94(p<0.0001)之间。与通过其他技术获得的平均脂肪相比,使用红外交互作用时,研究组的平均脂肪被低估了15%。还注意到,与其他技术相比,红外交互作用仪器得出的女性身体脂肪范围非常窄。在红外交互作用在身体成分分析中发挥重要作用之前,必须解决这些差异。