Wells P G, Kim P M, Laposa R R, Nicol C J, Parman T, Winn L M
Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto, Ont., Canada.
Mutat Res. 1997 Dec 12;396(1-2):65-78. doi: 10.1016/s0027-5107(97)00175-9.
The teratogenicity of many xenobiotics is thought to depend at least in part upon their bioactivation by embryonic cytochromes P450, prostaglandin H synthase (PHS) and lipoxygenases (LPOs) to electrophilic and/or free radical reactive intermediates that covalently bind to or oxidize cellular macromolecules such as DNA, protein and lipid, resulting in in utero death or teratogenesis. Using as models the tobacco carcinogens benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) and 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK), the anticonvulsant drug phenytoin, structurally related anticonvulsants (e.g. mephenytoin, nirvanol, trimethadione, dimethadione) and the sedative drug thalidomide, we have examined the potential teratologic relevance of free radical-initiated, reactive oxygen species (ROS)-mediated oxidative molecular target damage, genotoxicity (micronucleus formation) and DNA repair in mouse and rabbit models in vivo and in embryo culture, and in vitro using purified enzymes or cultured rat skin fibroblasts. These teratogens were bioactivated by PHS and LPOs to free radical reactive intermediary metabolites, characterized by electron spin resonance spectrometry, that initiated ROS formation, including hydroxyl radicals, which were characterized by salicylate hydroxylation. ROS-initiated oxidation of DNA (8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine formation), protein (carbonyl formation), glutathione (GSH) and lipid (peroxidation), and embryotoxicity were shown for phenytoin, its major hydroxylated metabolite 5-(p-hydroxyphenyl)-5-phenylhydantoin [HPPH], thalidomide, B[a]P and NNK in vivo and/or in embryo culture, the latter indicating a teratologically critical role for embryonic, as distinct from maternal, processes. DNA oxidation and teratogenicity of phenytoin and thalidomide were reduced by PHS inhibitors. Oxidative macromolecular lesions and teratogenicity also were reduced by the free radical trapping agent phenylbutylnitrone (PBN), and the antioxidants caffeic acid and vitamin E. In embryo culture, addition of superoxide dismutase (SOD) to the medium enhanced embryonic SOD activity, and SOD or catalase blocked the oxidative lesions and embryotoxicity initiated by phenytoin and B[a]P, suggesting a major contribution of ROS, as distinct from covalent binding, to the teratologic mechanism. In in vivo studies, other antioxidative enzymes like GSH peroxidase, GSH reductase and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) were similarly protective. Even untreated G6PD-deficient mice had enhanced embryopathies, indicating a teratological role for endogenous oxidative stress. In cultured fibroblasts, B[a]P, NNK, phenytoin and HPPH initiated DNA oxidation and micronucleus formation, which were inhibited by SOD. Oxidation of DNA may be particularly critical, since transgenic mice with +/- or -/- deficiencies in the p53 tumor suppressor gene, which facilitates DNA repair, are more susceptible to phenytoin and B[a]P teratogenicity. Even p53-deficient mice treated only with normal saline showed enhanced embryopathies, suggesting the teratological importance of endogenous oxidative stress, as observed with G6PD deficiency. These results suggest that oxidative macromolecular damage may play a role in the teratologic mechanism of xenobiotics that are bioactivated to a reactive intermediate, as well in the mechanism of embryopathies occurring in the absence of xenobiotic exposure.
许多外源性物质的致畸性被认为至少部分取决于它们被胚胎细胞色素P450、前列腺素H合酶(PHS)和脂氧合酶(LPO)生物活化,形成亲电和/或自由基反应性中间体,这些中间体与细胞大分子如DNA、蛋白质和脂质共价结合或氧化,导致子宫内死亡或致畸。以烟草致癌物苯并[a]芘(B[a]P)和4-(甲基亚硝胺基)-1-(3-吡啶基)-1-丁酮(NNK)、抗惊厥药物苯妥英、结构相关的抗惊厥药物(如美芬妥英、尼瓦诺、三甲双酮、二甲双酮)以及镇静药物沙利度胺为模型,我们在小鼠和兔体内及胚胎培养模型中,以及在体外使用纯化酶或培养的大鼠皮肤成纤维细胞,研究了自由基引发的、活性氧(ROS)介导的氧化分子靶点损伤、遗传毒性(微核形成)和DNA修复的潜在致畸学相关性。这些致畸剂被PHS和LPO生物活化形成自由基反应性中间代谢产物,通过电子自旋共振光谱法进行表征,这些中间代谢产物引发ROS形成,包括通过水杨酸羟化表征的羟基自由基。在体内和/或胚胎培养中显示,苯妥英、其主要羟基化代谢产物5-(对羟基苯基)-5-苯基乙内酰脲[HPPH]、沙利度胺、B[a]P和NNK可引发ROS引发的DNA氧化(8-羟基-2'-脱氧鸟苷形成)、蛋白质氧化(羰基形成)、谷胱甘肽(GSH)氧化和脂质氧化(过氧化)以及胚胎毒性,后者表明胚胎过程(与母体过程不同)在致畸方面具有关键作用。PHS抑制剂可降低苯妥英和沙利度胺的DNA氧化和致畸性。自由基捕获剂苯基丁基硝酮(PBN)以及抗氧化剂咖啡酸和维生素E也可降低氧化大分子损伤和致畸性。在胚胎培养中,向培养基中添加超氧化物歧化酶(SOD)可增强胚胎SOD活性,SOD或过氧化氢酶可阻断苯妥英和B[a]P引发的氧化损伤和胚胎毒性,这表明ROS(与共价结合不同)在致畸机制中起主要作用。在体内研究中,其他抗氧化酶如GSH过氧化物酶、GSH还原酶和葡萄糖-6-磷酸脱氢酶(G6PD)也具有类似的保护作用。即使未处理的G6PD缺陷小鼠也有更多的胚胎病变,这表明内源性氧化应激在致畸方面具有作用。在培养的成纤维细胞中,B[a]P、NNK、苯妥英和HPPH引发DNA氧化和微核形成,而SOD可抑制这些反应。DNA氧化可能特别关键,因为p53肿瘤抑制基因(有助于DNA修复)存在+/-或-/-缺陷的转基因小鼠对苯妥英和B[a]P的致畸性更敏感。即使仅用生理盐水处理的p53缺陷小鼠也有更多的胚胎病变,这表明内源性氧化应激在致畸方面具有重要性,这与G6PD缺陷的情况相同。这些结果表明,氧化大分子损伤可能在被生物活化形成反应性中间体的外源性物质的致畸机制中起作用,也可能在无外源性物质暴露情况下发生的胚胎病变机制中起作用。