Clasby R, Tilling K, Smith M A, Fletcher C D
Soft Tissue Tumour Unit, St Thomas's Hospital (United Medical and Dental Schools), London, UK.
Br J Surg. 1997 Dec;84(12):1692-6.
The aim of this study was to determine how and by which specialties patients with soft tissue sarcoma are investigated and treated within a single large health region and with what outcomes and implications for resource uptake.
By retrieving the records of 377 patients with primary soft tissue sarcoma treated in the South-East Thames Region between 1986 and 1992, the presentation, investigation, treatment and outcome were compared with defined criteria for optimal management. Patient management was assessed and compared between specialties and districts on the basis of outpatient time, appropriate use of radiological investigations and preoperative biopsy, type of surgery, content of the pathology report and the incidence of local recurrence, metastasis and death over a mean follow-up period of 2.5 years.
Most patients (53.6 per cent) were treated by general surgeons, irrespective of tumour location. Overall only 21.3 per cent of patients were investigated optimally with wide variation among specialties. Only 60.0 per cent were treated adequately (wide excision or surgery with radiotherapy). Uptake of adjunctive therapy and follow-up were variable. Outcome was poorer in patients having a marginal excision and recurrence.
Investigation and management of many patients with soft tissue sarcoma was both variable and suboptimal. This has implications for patient care, resource uptake and costs. As has been amply demonstrated elsewhere, patients with sarcoma are more appropriately managed in specialist centres.
本研究旨在确定在一个大型健康区域内,软组织肉瘤患者是如何以及由哪些专科进行检查和治疗的,以及这对资源利用产生了何种结果和影响。
通过检索1986年至1992年间在泰晤士河东南部地区接受治疗的377例原发性软组织肉瘤患者的记录,将其临床表现、检查、治疗及结果与最佳治疗的既定标准进行比较。根据门诊时间、放射学检查及术前活检的合理应用、手术类型、病理报告内容以及在平均2.5年的随访期内局部复发、转移和死亡的发生率,对各专科和地区之间的患者管理进行评估和比较。
大多数患者(53.6%)由普通外科医生治疗,而不考虑肿瘤位置。总体而言,仅有21.3%的患者得到了最佳检查,各专科之间差异很大。只有60.0%的患者得到了充分治疗(广泛切除或手术加放疗)。辅助治疗的应用和随访情况各不相同。边缘切除和复发患者的预后较差。
许多软组织肉瘤患者的检查和管理存在差异且未达到最佳标准。这对患者护理、资源利用和成本都有影响。正如其他地方充分证明的那样,肉瘤患者在专科中心接受治疗更为合适。