Optimal bovine pericardial tissue selection sites. II. Cartographic analysis.

In Part I of this work we used small-angle light scattering (SALS) to quantify the fiber architecture of 20 bovine pericardial sacs, along with corresponding tissue-thickness measurements, to determine optimal material selection sites. In order to determine the anatomic consistency of these sites, the fiber architecture and thickness data from all 20 sacs were averaged together using a cartographic analysis method that took advantage of the geometry of the prolate spheroid mold used to process the sacs. Optimal selection sites were determined based on a local criteria where all fiber preferred directions within a 2.54-cm circular area were within +/- 10 degrees. The largest contiguous area (LCA) for the entire BP sac was 20.54 cm2, located in the vicinity of the left ventricle of the heart. The LCA tissue thicknesses were also relatively uniform, further supporting the use of these areas. However, even within these optimal areas there was a +/- 20 degrees standard deviation in local fiber preferred directions, resulting in at best a 40 degrees spread in local preferred directions. The observed structural variability may be due to regionally heterogeneous physiologic loadings induced by the ligamentous attachments. These attachments may alter the regional fiber preferred orientation to support local mechanical loadings. Overall, given the inherent structural variability of the BP sac, we conclude that use of anatomic location alone will not consistently guarantee the selection of tissue specimens with a highly homogeneous and predictable fibrous structure. It is thus suggested that a direct fiber measurement presorting method be employed when selecting BP specimens for bioprosthetic applications where tissue structural homogeneity and uniformity is critical.