Goodacre S W
Accident and Emergency Department, Leeds General Infirmary, UK.
J Accid Emerg Med. 1998 Jan;15(1):26-30. doi: 10.1136/emj.15.1.26.
To define the role of the accident and emergency (A&E) short stay ward by a survey of departments in the United Kingdom and review of published reports.
A postal questionnaire with telephone follow up to all major A&E departments with short stay beds.
95 departments were found to have short stay beds. These units received between 19000 and 121000 new patients per year (mean 51000, median 50500) and had access to between two and 20 beds (mean 7.5, median 6). The level of provision varied from one bed per 2440 new attendances to one bed per 27250 new attendances (mean 8380, median 6625). Where data on admission rates were available the departments admitted between 0.1% and 13.3% of their new attendances (mean 2.62%, median 1.9%). Cover was typically provided by an A&E senior house officer with frequent senior ward rounds. While the casemix usually included minor head injuries and alcohol intoxicated patients, there was considerable variation in the cases admitted.
Short stay provision is highly variable in the United Kingdom. While there are many reports of well run short stay units, consistent evidence of clinical value and cost-effectiveness compared to other methods of care is lacking. Further comparative studies are required to define the role of the A&E short stay ward.
通过对英国各科室的调查以及对已发表报告的回顾,明确急诊短期留观病房的作用。
向所有设有短期留观床位的主要急诊科邮寄问卷调查表,并进行电话随访。
发现95个科室设有短期留观床位。这些科室每年接收19000至121000名新患者(平均51000名,中位数50500名),拥有2至20张床位(平均7.5张,中位数6张)。床位配备水平从每2440名新就诊患者1张床位到每27250名新就诊患者1张床位不等(平均8380名,中位数6625名)。在可获得入院率数据的科室中,新就诊患者的入院率在0.1%至13.3%之间(平均2.62%,中位数1.9%)。通常由急诊高级住院医师提供护理,并经常进行上级医师查房。虽然病例组合通常包括轻度头部损伤和酒精中毒患者,但入院病例存在很大差异。
在英国,短期留观服务的提供情况差异很大。虽然有许多关于运作良好的短期留观病房的报告,但与其他护理方法相比,缺乏临床价值和成本效益的一致证据。需要进一步的比较研究来明确急诊短期留观病房的作用。