Klein U, Karzai W, Bloos F, Wohlfarth M, Gottschall R, Fritz H, Gugel M, Seifert A
Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine, University Hospital, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Germany.
Anesthesiology. 1998 Feb;88(2):346-50. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199802000-00012.
Fiberoptic bronchoscopy has been recommended to verify the position of double-lumen tubes (DLT), but this remains controversial. The authors studied the role of bronchoscopy for placing and monitoring right- and left-sided DLTs after blind intubation and after positioning the patient.
Two hundred patients having thoracic surgery requiring DLT insertion were prospectively studied. "Blind" tracheal intubations were done with 163 left-sided and 37 right-sided disposable polyvinyl chloride Robertshaw tubes. Bronchoscopy was performed by a different anesthesiologist after intubation and conventional clinical verification of correct placement and after patient positioning for thoracotomy. A DLT was considered malpositioned when it had to be moved >0.5 cm to correct its position. Critical malpositions were those that might have affected patient safety or influenced the surgical procedure if left uncorrected.
After "blind" DLT intubation, clinical evidence of malpositioning was found in 28 patients. This was confirmed by fiberoptic assessment. In 172 patients in whom placement was judged correct by clinical assessment, malpositioning was detected by bronchoscopy in 79 cases, 25 of which were critical. After patient positioning, DLTs were found to be displaced in 93 patients, 48 of which were critical. Right-sided DLTs were significantly more likely to be malpositioned than were left-sided DLTs. Two complications were related to unsatisfactory lung separation in the 200 patients studied.
After blind intubation and patient positioning, more than one third of DLTs required repositioning. Routine bronchoscopy is therefore recommended after intubation and after patient positioning.
纤维支气管镜已被推荐用于确认双腔气管导管(DLT)的位置,但这仍存在争议。作者研究了支气管镜在盲目插管后及患者体位摆放后放置和监测右侧及左侧DLT中的作用。
前瞻性研究了200例需要插入DLT进行胸外科手术的患者。使用163根左侧和37根右侧一次性聚氯乙烯罗伯特肖导管进行“盲目”气管插管。插管后,在通过传统临床方法确认导管放置正确后以及患者摆好开胸手术体位后,由另一位麻醉医生进行支气管镜检查。当DLT必须移动超过0.5 cm以纠正其位置时,认为其位置不当。严重位置不当是指如果不纠正可能会影响患者安全或影响手术操作的情况。
“盲目”插入DLT后,28例患者出现位置不当的临床证据。这通过纤维支气管镜评估得到证实。在172例经临床评估认为放置正确的患者中,支气管镜检查发现79例位置不当,其中25例为严重位置不当。患者体位摆放后,发现93例患者的DLT发生移位,其中48例为严重移位。右侧DLT比左侧DLT更易出现位置不当。在研究的200例患者中,有2例并发症与肺隔离不充分有关。
盲目插管和患者体位摆放后,超过三分之一的DLT需要重新定位。因此,建议在插管后和患者体位摆放后进行常规支气管镜检查。