Cohen J J
AAMC, Washington, DC 20037-1127, USA.
Acad Med. 1998 Feb;73(2):132-7. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199802000-00010.
Leadership in improving the education of doctors, while impressive, is not happening fast enough. While there are many obstacles, there is no time to waste in restructuring medical education to repair its present deficiencies, for otherwise outside forces could overwhelm today's education leaders with imperatives to make improvements on their own terms. The first step in addressing present shortcomings is to establish measurable objectives for the education of doctors that are aligned with the legitimate expectations of society and the enduring precepts of the medical profession. To provide guidance in establishing these objectives, the AAMC launched the Medical School Objectives Project (MSOP) two years ago. This project is now close to completing its initial phase, which is to define the knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values every medical student must demonstrate before graduating. Phase Two will be concerned with implementation (e.g., establishing assessment methods; improving faculty development; etc.). As for aligning the outcomes of medical education with the precepts of the profession, nothing is more important: if doctors do not have high standards of professionalism--altruism, respect, compassion, honesty, integrity, and others--medicine's very survival is threatened. Medical educators must insist that their graduates demonstrate these attributes, through more careful admission criteria, more attention to medical professionalism in the curriculum and in the evaluation of students, more community service for students, and improved role modeling by faculty. Leadership for the changes that are needed will not come from a once-in-a-lifetime leader of heroic proportions but from everyone within academic medicine leading the profession to its promising future through quality education.
在改善医生教育方面的领导力虽然令人印象深刻,但进展还不够快。尽管存在许多障碍,但现在没有时间可以浪费在重组医学教育以弥补其当前的不足上了,否则外部力量可能会迫使当今的教育领导者按照他们自己的条件进行改进,从而使其不堪重负。解决当前不足的第一步是为医生教育确立可衡量的目标,这些目标要与社会的合理期望以及医学专业的持久准则相一致。为了在确立这些目标方面提供指导,美国医学院协会(AAMC)两年前启动了医学院目标项目(MSOP)。该项目现已接近完成其初始阶段,即确定每个医学生在毕业前必须展示的知识、技能、态度和价值观。第二阶段将关注实施(例如,建立评估方法;改善教师发展等)。至于使医学教育的成果与专业准则保持一致,没有什么比这更重要的了:如果医生没有高标准的职业素养——利他主义、尊重、同情、诚实、正直等等——医学的生存本身就会受到威胁。医学教育工作者必须坚持要求他们的毕业生通过更严格的录取标准、在课程设置和学生评估中更多地关注医学职业素养、让学生更多地参与社区服务以及教师更好地发挥榜样作用来展现这些特质。所需变革的领导力不会来自一位具有英雄气概、千载难逢的领导者,而是来自学术医学领域的每一个人,他们通过高质量的教育引领这个行业走向充满希望的未来。