Acad Med. 1999 Jan;74(1):13-8. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199901000-00010.
Many observers of medicine have expressed concerns that new doctors are not as well prepared as they should be to meet society's expectations of them. To assist medical schools in their efforts to respond to these concerns, in January 1996 the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) established the Medical School Objectives Project (MSOP). The goal for the first phase of the project--which has been completed and is reported in this article--was to develop a consensus within the medical education community on the attributes that medical students should possess at the time of graduation, and to set forth learning objectives that can guide each medical school as it establishes objectives for its own program. Later reports will focus on the implementation phase of the MSOP. In this report, each of the four attributes agreed upon by a wide spectrum of medical educators is stated and explained, and then the learning objectives associated with the school's instilling of that attribute are stated. The first of the four attributes is that physicians must be altruistic. There are seven learning objectives, including the objective that before graduation, the student can demonstrate compassionate treatment of patients and respect for their privacy and dignity. The second attribute is that physicians must be knowledgeable; one of the six learning objectives is that the student can demonstrate knowledge of the normal structure and function of the body and of each of its major organ systems. The third attribute is that physicians must be skillful; one of the eleven learning objectives is that the student have knowledge about relieving pain and ameliorating the suffering of patients. The last attribute is that physicians must be dutiful; one of the six learning objectives is that the student have knowledge of the epidemiology of common maladies within a defined population, and the systematic approaches useful in reducing the incidence and prevalence of those maladies. The report ends by stating that (1) if a school's curriculum is shaped by the set of learning objectives presented in the report, the graduates will be well prepared to assume the limited patient care responsibilities expected of new residents and also will have begun to achieve the attributes needed to practice contemporary medicine; (2) schools should feel a sense of urgency in responding to the intent of the report; and (3) it is important to measure the outcomes of learning objectives, and better assessment methods should be developed, particularly ones to assess outcomes related to attitudes and values.
许多医学观察家都表达了担忧,认为新医生在满足社会对他们的期望方面准备不足。为了帮助医学院应对这些担忧,1996年1月,美国医学院协会(AAMC)设立了医学院目标项目(MSOP)。该项目第一阶段的目标——已完成并在本文中报告——是在医学教育界就医学学生毕业时应具备的素质达成共识,并提出学习目标,以指导每所医学院为其自身项目设定目标。后续报告将聚焦于MSOP的实施阶段。在本报告中,阐述并解释了广泛的医学教育工作者所认同的四个素质中的每一个,然后陈述了与学校灌输该素质相关的学习目标。四个素质中的第一个是医生必须具备利他精神。有七个学习目标,包括在毕业前,学生能够表现出对患者的同情治疗,并尊重他们的隐私和尊严。第二个素质是医生必须知识渊博;六个学习目标之一是学生能够展示对人体正常结构和功能及其每个主要器官系统的了解。第三个素质是医生必须技术娴熟;十一个学习目标之一是学生具备缓解患者疼痛和减轻其痛苦的知识。最后一个素质是医生必须尽职尽责;六个学习目标之一是学生了解特定人群中常见疾病的流行病学,以及有助于降低这些疾病发病率和患病率的系统方法。报告最后指出:(1)如果一所学校的课程由报告中提出的一系列学习目标塑造,毕业生将做好充分准备,承担新住院医生预期的有限患者护理责任,并且也将开始具备从事当代医学所需的素质;(2)学校应在回应报告意图方面感到紧迫感;(3)衡量学习目标的成果很重要,应开发更好的评估方法,特别是用于评估与态度和价值观相关成果的方法。