Petrone D, De Candia N, Cassano P
Divisione di Otorinolaringoiatria ASL BA/4, Ospedale Civile di Bitonto, Bari.
Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital. 1997 Jun;17(3):215-8.
The authors report 12 cases of bilateral cupulolithiasis found in 142 subjects diagnosed as having benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. A case history was taken for these patients (4 males, 8 females; average age 28 years) and 10 reported a previous cranial trauma while the remainder did not refer any previous condition of note. All patients had normal cochleovestibular test results and showed no signs of concomitant internal and/or central pathologies. The Hallpike maneuver was able to evoke an intense symmetrical paroxysmal vertigo and this was often accompanied by neurovegetative phenomena while paroxysmal nystagmus always appeared. The patients were treated with a rehabilitative technique: the Brandt-Daroff was preferred as it is better tolerated. Within 15 days all patients had full remission of symptoms and at 6 months after treatment there have been no signs of recurrence. The conclusion is, thus, drawn that while the technical characteristics of the Sémont maneuver make it suitable only for use as rehabilitation in unilateral benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, this experience indicates that the Brandt-Daroff technique is better suited for the bilateral forms of this disorder.
作者报告了在142例被诊断为良性阵发性位置性眩晕的患者中发现的12例双侧嵴顶结石症病例。对这些患者(4名男性,8名女性;平均年龄28岁)进行了病史采集,其中10例报告曾有颅脑外伤史,其余患者未提及任何值得注意的既往病史。所有患者的耳蜗前庭测试结果均正常,且未显示出伴有内耳和/或中枢病变的迹象。Hallpike手法能够诱发强烈的对称性阵发性眩晕,且常伴有神经植物性现象,同时总会出现阵发性眼球震颤。患者接受了一种康复技术治疗:首选Brandt-Daroff法,因为它的耐受性更好。15天内所有患者症状完全缓解,治疗后6个月无复发迹象。因此得出的结论是,虽然Sémont手法的技术特点使其仅适用于单侧良性阵发性位置性眩晕的康复治疗,但该经验表明Brandt-Daroff技术更适合这种疾病的双侧形式。