Cunney R J, McNamara E B, Alansari N, Loo B, Smyth E G
Department of Clinical Microbiology, Royal College of Surgeons, Dublin 9, Ireland.
J Clin Pathol. 1997 Dec;50(12):1010-2. doi: 10.1136/jcp.50.12.1010.
To assess the impact of blood culture results and early clinical liaison on the treatment of patients with bacteraemia.
123 patients with significant positive blood cultures were followed over a nine month period in a 620 bed teaching hospital. The impact of early blood culture reporting and clinical liaison on the cost and appropriateness of treatment was assessed.
Empiric treatment was started before the Gram stain result in 107 (87%) patients. Treatment was altered on the basis of the Gram stain result in 39 (36%) of these patients, and on culture and sensitivity results in 53 (50%). The spectrum of antibiotic treatment was narrowed in 58 (54%) of these; 20 (19%) on Gram stain result alone. This resulted in a 42% reduction in daily antibiotic costs in patients who had received empiric treatment. Empiric treatment did not follow the hospital antibiotic policy in 49 (46%) of the patients treated. In patients where empiric treatment was not in accordance with hospital policy, 21 (44%) had an isolate resistant to the empiric treatment used; while in patients who received agents in accordance with hospital policy only one (1.7%) had a resistant isolate (p < 0.05). Patients who died (11 (9%)) were less likely to have received empiric treatment in accordance with the antibiotic policy, although this did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.1).
Early reporting of Gram stain results from blood cultures, combined with early clinical liaison, results in more rational and cost effective treatment.
评估血培养结果及早期临床沟通对菌血症患者治疗的影响。
在一家拥有620张床位的教学医院,对123例血培养显著阳性的患者进行了为期9个月的随访。评估了早期血培养报告及临床沟通对治疗成本和合理性的影响。
107例(87%)患者在革兰氏染色结果出来之前就开始了经验性治疗。其中39例(36%)患者根据革兰氏染色结果调整了治疗方案,53例(50%)根据培养及药敏结果调整了治疗方案。这些患者中有58例(54%)的抗生素治疗范围变窄;仅根据革兰氏染色结果就有20例(19%)。这使得接受经验性治疗的患者每日抗生素费用降低了42%。49例(46%)接受治疗的患者,其经验性治疗未遵循医院抗生素政策。在经验性治疗不符合医院政策的患者中,21例(44%)的分离菌对所用的经验性治疗耐药;而在接受符合医院政策药物治疗的患者中,只有1例(1.7%)有耐药分离菌(p<0.05)。死亡患者(11例(9%))不太可能接受符合抗生素政策的经验性治疗,尽管这未达到统计学显著性(p=0.1)。
血培养革兰氏染色结果的早期报告,结合早期临床沟通,可使治疗更合理且更具成本效益。