Wang Y L, Tsau J C, Huang M H, Lee B F, Li C H
Department of Rehabilitation, Chi-Mei Foundation Hospital, Taiwan, Republic of China.
Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 1998 Jan;14(1):40-7.
In an attempt to investigate the correlation between three phase bone scintigraphy (TPBS) and the clinical manifestation of reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome (RSDS) in the upper extremity of hemiplegia, we collected 30 patients with cerebral vascular accidents (CVA) confirmed by head computed tomography (infarction or hemorrhage) within 3 months of their CVA event. All patients received TPBS after admission. Clinical assessment for the development of the RSDS was done at least 3 months (268 +/- 120 days) after the stroke. The correlation between the development of RSD and certain clinical variables (including sex, age, side affected, caused of stroke, and motor stage) were analyzed. Twelve patients (40%) manifested definite or probable RSDS, as assessed by Tepperman's criteria, during the follow-up period. Nineteen patients (63%) exhibited radionuclide evidence of RSDS based on delayed bone scan criteria performed within 3 months (43 +/- 25 days) of the stroke. The positive delayed image of TPBS demonstrated a sensitivity = 92%; specificity = 56%; positive predictive value = 58%, and negative predictive value = 91%. The Kappa statistics for agreement between positive bone scan and RSDS development was 70% (Kappa = 0.43, p < 0.05). Neither sex, age, side affected, cause of stroke, or motor stage had a significant correlation with clinical RSDS. In conclusion, TPBS is a useful screening tool for the development of RSD in hemiplegic patients. However, the diagnosis of RSDS depends on the clinical evaluation and that TPBS as an adjunct assessment of RSDS must be interpreted with caution.
为了研究三相骨闪烁显像(TPBS)与偏瘫上肢反射性交感神经营养不良综合征(RSDS)临床表现之间的相关性,我们收集了30例经头颅计算机断层扫描(梗死或出血)确诊为脑血管意外(CVA)且发病在3个月内的患者。所有患者入院后均接受TPBS检查。对RSDS发生情况的临床评估在卒中后至少3个月(268±120天)进行。分析了RSD的发生与某些临床变量(包括性别、年龄、患侧、卒中病因和运动阶段)之间的相关性。在随访期间,根据Tepperman标准评估,12例患者(40%)表现为明确或可能的RSDS。19例患者(63%)在卒中后3个月(43±25天)内根据延迟骨扫描标准显示有RSDS的放射性核素证据。TPBS延迟显像的阳性结果显示敏感性=92%;特异性=56%;阳性预测值=58%,阴性预测值=91%。骨扫描阳性与RSDS发生之间的一致性Kappa统计值为70%(Kappa=0.43,p<0.05)。性别、年龄、患侧、卒中病因或运动阶段与临床RSDS均无显著相关性。总之,TPBS是偏瘫患者RSD发生情况的一种有用筛查工具。然而,RSDS的诊断取决于临床评估,作为RSDS辅助评估手段的TPBS必须谨慎解读。