Welling D B, Martyn M D, Miles B A, Oehler M, Schmalbrock P
Department of Otolaryngology, The Ohio State University, Columbus 43210, USA.
Am J Otol. 1998 Mar;19(2):145-51.
To test the efficacy of occlusion of the enlarged vestibular aqueduct to treat the progressive sensorineural hearing loss associated with the enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA) syndrome.
Prospective controlled study.
Tertiary care referral center.
Sixteen consecutive patients (29 affected ears) with progressive sensorineural hearing loss and vestibular aqueducts >1.5 mm in diameter without other inner ear anomalies participated in this study.
In 10 patients with progressive hearing loss, the EVA was occluded in the ear with worse hearing by placing a fascia graft between the posterior fossa dura overlying the endolymphatic sac and intraosseous duct and the posterior semicircular canal without opening the endolymphatic sac. In the operative ears, serial postoperative audiograms were compared with the contralateral ear in patients with bilateral EVA and with the other nonoperated control ears.
The rate of decline of pure-tone average and speech discrimination before surgery in the operated ear was compared with the rate of decline postoperatively in the same ear. The rates of decline in the nonoperated contralateral ear from the same patient and the nonoperated control ears from other patients were also used for comparison with the postoperative rate of decline in the operated ears.
There was no statistically significant change in the rate of hearing loss in patients undergoing occlusion of the EVA.
Extraluminal soft-tissue occlusion of the EVA appears to be a safe procedure but has not yet been shown to be significantly effective in altering the sensorineural hearing loss accompanying the EVA syndrome. Further surgical intervention does not appear warranted until such time that longitudinal follow-up shows sufficient evidence of efficacy of the procedure.
测试阻塞扩大的前庭导水管治疗与扩大的前庭导水管(EVA)综合征相关的进行性感音神经性听力损失的疗效。
前瞻性对照研究。
三级医疗转诊中心。
16例连续的进行性感音神经性听力损失患者(29只患耳),其前庭导水管直径>1.5mm且无其他内耳异常,参与了本研究。
对于10例进行性听力损失患者,通过在覆盖内淋巴囊和骨内导管的后颅窝硬脑膜与后半规管之间放置筋膜移植物,而不打开内淋巴囊,阻塞听力较差耳的EVA。在手术耳中,将双侧EVA患者手术耳术后的系列听力图与对侧耳进行比较,并与其他未手术的对照耳进行比较。
将手术耳术前纯音平均听阈和言语识别率的下降率与术后同一耳的下降率进行比较。还将同一患者未手术的对侧耳以及其他患者未手术的对照耳的下降率与手术耳术后的下降率进行比较。
进行EVA阻塞术的患者听力损失率无统计学意义上的显著变化。
EVA的管外软组织阻塞似乎是一种安全的手术,但尚未显示出对改变EVA综合征伴随的感音神经性听力损失有显著效果。在纵向随访显示该手术有足够疗效证据之前,似乎没有必要进行进一步的手术干预。