Shepherd M, Gunnell D, Maxwell B, Mumford D
Department of Public Health Medicine, Avon Health Authority, Bristol, UK.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1998 Mar;33(3):129-35. doi: 10.1007/s001270050033.
The objective of this study was to examine the development and activity of a Community Mental Health Team, originally targeted to meet the needs of African Caribbean, Asian and homeless populations in an inner city area. The study was based on all (n = 1046) client referrals to the Bristol Inner City Community Mental Health Team between 1987 and 1994. Additional qualitative interviews were held with general practitioners (GPs) from each of the nine practices in the area. The setting was the inner city area of Bristol, an area with a population of around 35,000 27% of whom are from ethnic minority communities. This is an area shown in previous research to have a high level of mental health problems. Trends in referral rates, demographic characteristics and seriousness of psychiatric illness amongst those referred to the Inner City Mental Health Team were the main outcome measures used. In the years studied there were significant increases in the number and proportion of overall referrals from GPs and psychiatrists and decreases in referrals from other agencies. In particular, there were reductions in the referral both of clients from the originally identified target groups and of patients with serious mental illness. GPs tended to refer a greater proportion of patients with less serious mental illness. The results of the study showed that a team originally developed to meet the needs of the homeless and those from ethnic minorities has, with the removal of special project funding, shifted its focus away from the client groups for whom it was originally developed to those with less serious mental health problems. These changes are partially attributable both to changes in the remit of the team, making it more acceptable to GPs, and to a growing acceptance of community-based mental health services among GPs and their patients. Changes in the geographic catchment area served by the team has also played a role in the observed trends. Commissioners of mental health services need to bear in mind the needs of high-risk groups when making contracts. It may be that in order to meet effectively the needs of inner city populations with a high prevalence of mental health problems, there is a need for specialist teams with a specific remit.
本研究的目的是考察一个社区心理健康团队的发展与活动,该团队最初旨在满足市中心区非洲加勒比裔、亚裔及无家可归人群的需求。本研究基于1987年至1994年间转介至布里斯托尔市中心社区心理健康团队的所有(n = 1046)客户。此外,还对该地区九个诊所的全科医生进行了定性访谈。研究地点为布里斯托尔市中心区,该地区人口约35000人,其中27%来自少数民族社区。此前的研究表明,该地区心理健康问题高发。转介至市中心心理健康团队的转诊率、人口统计学特征及精神疾病严重程度的趋势是主要的研究结果指标。在所研究的年份中,全科医生和精神科医生的总体转诊数量及比例显著增加,而其他机构的转诊数量减少。特别是,最初确定的目标群体中的客户以及患有严重精神疾病的患者的转诊数量减少。全科医生倾向于转诊精神疾病不太严重的患者。研究结果表明,一个最初为满足无家可归者和少数民族需求而设立的团队,在取消专项项目资金后,其关注重点已从最初设立时针对的客户群体转向精神健康问题不太严重的人群。这些变化部分归因于团队职责范围的变化,使其更易被全科医生接受,也归因于全科医生及其患者对社区心理健康服务的接受度不断提高。团队服务的地理覆盖区域的变化也在观察到的趋势中起到了作用。心理健康服务的委托方在签订合同时需要考虑高危群体的需求。可能为了有效满足市中心心理健康问题高发人群的需求,需要设立具有特定职责范围的专业团队。