Klingenheben T, Zabel M, Hohnloser S H
J.-W.-Goethe-Universität, Medizinische Klinik IV/Kardiologie, Frankfurt a. M., Germany.
Z Kardiol. 1998 Feb;87(2):128-33. doi: 10.1007/s003920050164.
Heart rate variability (HRV) has been established as an important risk parameter in patients surviving myocardial infarction. Recently, analysis of HRV-particularly of the standard deviation of NN intervals (SDNN)--from short term ECG recordings has been proposed as an alternative to that from 24 hour Holter monitorings. The present study is the first to compare SDNN from short term recordings to that from 24 hour recordings with respect to risk stratification after myocardial infarction. In 60 patients at the time of discharge from the hospital, SDNN from Holter monitoring averaged 93 +/- 30 ms compared to 39 +/- 18 determined from short term recordings. Patients with a prospectively defined clinical endpoint differed significantly from those with an uneventful course with respect to age, left ventricular ejection fraction, mean RR interval from Holter recording (753 +/- 153 vs 921 +/- 132 ms), mean RR from short term recording (783 +/- 153 vs 914 +/- 163 ms), and SDNN from the Hotler recording (71 +/- 27 vs 97 +/- 29 ms; p < 0.001). However, patients with and without a clinical event could not be separated by means of SDNN measured from short term ECG registrations (35 +/- 22 vs 41 +/- 19 ms; p = NS). Thus, SDNN measured from short term ECG recordings does not seem to be useful regarding risk stratification of patients after myocardial infarction. Analysis of HRV should be performed using 24 hour Holter monitoring, which provides more information and reflects circadian fluctuation in autonomic tone.
心率变异性(HRV)已被确立为心肌梗死存活患者的一项重要风险参数。最近,有人提出,通过短期心电图记录分析HRV,尤其是NN间期标准差(SDNN),可替代24小时动态心电图监测。本研究首次比较了短期记录所得的SDNN与24小时记录所得的SDNN在心肌梗死后风险分层方面的差异。60例患者出院时,动态心电图监测所得的SDNN平均为93±30毫秒,而短期记录所得的SDNN为39±18毫秒。具有前瞻性定义临床终点的患者与病情平稳的患者在年龄、左心室射血分数、动态心电图记录的平均RR间期(753±153对921±132毫秒)、短期记录的平均RR间期(783±153对914±163毫秒)以及动态心电图记录的SDNN(71±27对97±29毫秒;p<0.001)方面存在显著差异。然而,根据短期心电图记录测得的SDNN无法区分有无临床事件的患者(35±22对41±19毫秒;p=无显著性差异)。因此,短期心电图记录测得的SDNN似乎对心肌梗死后患者的风险分层没有用处。HRV分析应采用24小时动态心电图监测,其能提供更多信息并反映自主神经张力的昼夜波动。