Parker T, May P A, Maviglia M A, Petrakis S, Sunde S, Gloyd S V
Case Western Reserve University, USA.
Int J Psychiatry Med. 1997;27(2):107-28. doi: 10.2190/C6FD-7QWB-KNGR-M844.
To examine the utility of using PRIME-MD (Primary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders) for diagnosing mental disorders in American Indians.
One hundred randomly selected, adult, American-Indian patients who receive health care services at an urban Indian Health Service primary care clinic were evaluated for mental disorder by three primary care physicians using the PRIME-MD diagnostic assessment procedure. The main outcome measures were PRIME-MD diagnoses, diagnoses by an independent mental health professional, and treatment/referral decisions.
Eighteen percent of the patients had a threshold (met full DSM-IV criteria ) PRIME-MD diagnosis, and an additional 17 percent had a subthreshold PRIME-MD diagnosis. The most frequently occurring PRIME-MD diagnoses were: probable alcohol abuse/dependence, major depressive disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder. Over 60 percent of the patients with a PRIME-MD diagnosis who were known "somewhat" or "fairly well" to their physician had not been recognized as having that psychiatric disorder prior to the PRIME-MD assessment. Therapy and/or referral was initiated for nineteen of the twenty-seven patients with a PRIME-MD diagnosis who were not previously receiving treatment. The primary care physicians were able to complete the PRIME-MD evaluations within an average of 7.8 minutes. There was a fair agreement between the PRIME-MD diagnoses and the diagnoses of the mental health professional (kappa = 0.56; overall accuracy rate = 79%).
The present study represents the first formal examination of the use of PRIME-MD with American Indians. The results are encouraging. Further studies using PRIME-MD with other urban groups and reservation populations are recommended.
研究使用PRIME-MD(精神障碍初级保健评估)诊断美国印第安人精神障碍的效用。
从一家城市印第安人健康服务初级保健诊所随机选取100名接受医疗服务的成年美国印第安患者,由三名初级保健医生使用PRIME-MD诊断评估程序对其精神障碍进行评估。主要结局指标为PRIME-MD诊断结果、独立精神健康专业人员的诊断结果以及治疗/转诊决定。
18%的患者有阈上(符合完整的《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版标准)PRIME-MD诊断,另有17%的患者有阈下PRIME-MD诊断。最常出现的PRIME-MD诊断为:可能的酒精滥用/依赖、重度抑郁症和广泛性焦虑症。在其医生对病情“有些”或“相当”了解的PRIME-MD诊断患者中,超过60%在PRIME-MD评估之前未被识别出患有该精神疾病。在27名之前未接受治疗的PRIME-MD诊断患者中,有19名开始接受治疗和/或转诊。初级保健医生平均能在7.8分钟内完成PRIME-MD评估。PRIME-MD诊断结果与精神健康专业人员的诊断结果之间有较好的一致性(kappa = 0.56;总体准确率 = 79%)。
本研究是对PRIME-MD在美国印第安人中应用的首次正式检验。结果令人鼓舞。建议对其他城市群体和保留地人群使用PRIME-MD进行进一步研究。