Weiss W P
Department of Animal Sciences, Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center, Ohio State University, Wooster 44691, USA.
J Dairy Sci. 1998 Mar;81(3):830-9. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(98)75641-3.
The available energy content of feeds must be known before diets can be formulated, but the difficulty in measuring energy availability requires that estimated values be used. Based on production data, the current system using net energy for lactation (NEL) or total digestible nutrients (TDN) over-valued the energy in feeds by 7 to 8%. A standard discount of 8 TDN units was used for both NEL and TDN. When the discount was calculated from actual intake (4 units per increment of maintenance), feed values for NEL and TDN were overestimated by 5 to 6%. Most feed values for NEL and TDN are estimated from acid detergent fiber. These models do not account for all sources of variation in digestibility, do not allow for variable discounts based on intake and associative effects, and are specific for a given population. Mechanistic models account for many sources of variation and can be modified to include variable discounts based on digestion and passage kinetics. The equation used to convert TDN to NEL does not consider the source of the digestible energy. The NEL of the fat that is contained within feeds is under-valued, and fiber is probably overvalued. Single-component equations are not adequate to describe the complex processes that determine energy availability. The current NEL and TDN systems overvalue the energy in feeds, but both systems still work remarkably well. These systems need to be modified to improve accuracy, but they should not be discarded.
在制定日粮之前,必须了解饲料的可利用能量含量,但由于测量能量可利用性存在困难,因此需要使用估计值。根据生产数据,当前使用泌乳净能(NEL)或总可消化养分(TDN)的系统将饲料中的能量高估了7%至8%。NEL和TDN都采用了8个TDN单位的标准折扣。当根据实际摄入量计算折扣时(每增加一个维持量单位为4个单位),NEL和TDN的饲料价值被高估了5%至6%。大多数NEL和TDN的饲料价值是根据酸性洗涤纤维估算的。这些模型没有考虑消化率变化的所有来源,不允许根据摄入量和协同效应进行可变折扣,并且是针对特定群体的。机理模型考虑了许多变化来源,可以进行修改以纳入基于消化和通过动力学的可变折扣。用于将TDN转换为NEL的方程没有考虑可消化能量的来源。饲料中所含脂肪的NEL被低估,而纤维可能被高估。单组分方程不足以描述决定能量可利用性的复杂过程。当前的NEL和TDN系统高估了饲料中的能量,但这两个系统仍然运行得非常好。这些系统需要进行修改以提高准确性,但不应被舍弃。