Gralewicz S, Soćko R
Department of Toxicology and Carcinogenesis, Nofer Institute of Occupational Medicine, Lódź, Poland.
Int J Occup Med Environ Health. 1997;10(4):375-94.
Organophosphorous compounds (OPs) constitute a large proportion of insecticides used all over the world. Their insecticidal properties and acute toxicity in nontarget species derive from the inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) which disturbs the cholinergically mediated neurotransmission. OPs do not accumulate in living organisms and the acute signs and symptoms disappear as the AChE activity returns to normal level. Therefore, they are regarded as relatively safe. However, as some literature data suggest, after either acute or prolonged exposure to OPs subtle neurobehavioral impairments may persist long after normalization of AChE activity. The possibility that OPs exposure may induce such long-term effects is nowadays a problem of great concern for the regulatory agencies. Here we present a review of studies from our laboratory aimed at detecting neurobehavioural effects of exposure to chlorphenvinphos, an OP pesticide ((2-chloro-1-(2,4-dichlorophenyl) vinyl diethyl phosphate)--CVP)) in laboratory animals. In Poland, CVP is manufactured (250 tons/year) and used for crop protection. In a series of experiments we have demonstrated that: a) in rabbits, two i.p. exposures to CVP at the same sublethal dose at three-month interval resulted in a similar inhibition of blood AChE activity but the effect of the second exposure on body temperature and hippocampal EEG was smaller and less consistent than that of the first one. This would indicate that some permanent changes within the CNS may occur even after a single exposure to CVP; b) in rats, under conditions of repeated i.p. exposure to CVP (one injection/day for ten days) at a symptomatic (3.0 mg/kg) dose inhibiting blood and brain AChE activity by about 80%, the tolerance to CVP, assessed from the spontaneous locomotor behaviour, developed within four to five days. However, single exposure to CVP at a symptomatic (3.0 mg/kg) or subsymptomatic (1.0 mg/kg, less than 50% AChE inhibition) dose, or repeated exposure (one injection/day, for ten days) at subsymptomatic doses (1.0 mg/kg or 0.5 mg/kg) resulted in subtle changes in complex behaviours detectable after AChE activity in blood and in the brain had returned to the normal level. The changes--neophobia in the open field, an increased and more persistent emotional response to a stressful stimulus, and increased EEG arousal response to an external pain signalling stimulus--suggest an increased reactivity of the system or systems responsible for the induction of fear; c) direct intrahypothalamic injections of CVP, unlike those of oxotremorine, a direct stimulant of cholinergic muscarinic receptors, did not induce overt changes in the animal (rabbit) behaviour and EEG. This would indicate that the changes in the CNS functions after CVP exposure may be the consequence of increased cholinergic activity due to AChE inhibition rather than to a direct stimulation of cholinergic muscarinic receptors by CVP. The above findings provide experimental evidence that health effects of exposure to CVP, may persist after recovery of AChE activity in blood and in the brain.
有机磷化合物(OPs)在全球使用的杀虫剂中占很大比例。它们对非目标物种的杀虫特性和急性毒性源于对乙酰胆碱酯酶(AChE)的抑制,这会干扰胆碱能介导的神经传递。OPs不会在生物体内蓄积,随着AChE活性恢复到正常水平,急性症状和体征也会消失。因此,它们被认为相对安全。然而,正如一些文献数据所表明的那样,在急性或长期接触OPs后,即使AChE活性恢复正常,细微的神经行为损伤可能仍会长期存在。如今,接触OPs可能诱发这种长期影响的可能性是监管机构极为关注的问题。在此,我们对来自我们实验室的研究进行综述,这些研究旨在检测接触氯芬磷(一种OP农药,即(2-氯-1-(2,4-二氯苯基)乙烯基二乙基磷酸酯)——CVP)对实验动物神经行为的影响。在波兰,CVP的年产量为250吨,用于农作物保护。在一系列实验中我们证明:a)在兔子身上,间隔三个月以相同亚致死剂量进行两次腹腔注射CVP,会导致血液AChE活性受到类似抑制,但第二次注射对体温和海马脑电图的影响比第一次更小且更不稳定。这表明即使单次接触CVP,中枢神经系统内也可能发生一些永久性变化;b)在大鼠身上,在有症状(3.0毫克/千克)剂量下重复腹腔注射CVP(每天注射一次,持续十天),抑制血液和脑AChE活性约80%,从自发运动行为评估的对CVP的耐受性在四到五天内形成。然而,单次以有症状(3.0毫克/千克)或亚症状(1.0毫克/千克,AChE抑制小于50%)剂量接触CVP,或以亚症状剂量(1.0毫克/千克或0.5毫克/千克)重复接触(每天注射一次,持续十天),在血液和脑AChE活性恢复到正常水平后,会导致复杂行为出现细微变化。这些变化——在旷场试验中出现新物恐惧、对压力刺激的情绪反应增强且更持久,以及对外部疼痛信号刺激的脑电图觉醒反应增强——表明负责诱发恐惧的一个或多个系统的反应性增加;c)与直接刺激胆碱能毒蕈碱受体的氧化震颤素不同,直接向兔下丘脑内注射CVP不会引起动物行为和脑电图的明显变化。这表明接触CVP后中枢神经系统功能的变化可能是由于AChE抑制导致胆碱能活性增加的结果,而不是CVP直接刺激胆碱能毒蕈碱受体的结果。上述研究结果提供了实验证据,表明接触CVP对健康的影响在血液和脑AChE活性恢复后可能仍然存在。