Drayson M T, Chapman C E, Dunn J A, Olujohungbe A B, Maclennan I C
Department of Immunology, University of Birmingham Medical School.
Br J Haematol. 1998 Apr;101(1):195-202. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2141.1998.00648.x.
Plateau phase has been achieved in 64% of all newly diagnosed patients with multiple myeloma treated with the ABCM (adriamycin, BiCNU, cyclophosphamide and melphalan) regimen in the Medical Research Council (MRC) trials; this stable clinical stage of the disease is associated with no more than minimal symptoms. Several studies have found that alpha-interferon (alpha-IFN) maintenance therapy increases the duration of plateau phase, but it is less clear if this translates into prolonged survival. We report the effect of alpha-IFN on the duration of plateau phase and overall survival in a trial with 284 patients who were randomized to receive alpha2b-IFN (Intron-A) or no maintenance therapy during first plateau phase. The minimum follow-up after randomization was 21 months. There was no significant difference in the overall survival between the two treatment groups (X2=0.32, P=0.57). There was a trend towards longer relapse-free survival in the patients allocated alpha-IFN, but this trend to longer plateau phase was not statistically significant (X2 = 1.62, P = 0.2). Disease progression at relapse on alpha-IFN appears to be more severe with greater elevations from plateau levels of serum paraprotein (P = 0.06) and beta2-microglobulin (P= 0.03) levels. Physicians tended to start chemotherapy sooner after diagnosis of relapse when patients had received alpha-IFN (P = 0.16). Although, in common with most other studies, there is a trend for patients treated with alpha-IFN to have a longer plateau phase, this is counteracted by morbidity attributable to the treatment and a somewhat shortened survival post relapse. Meta-analysis of interferon trials is required to assess whether the minor trend for longer survival in patients maintained on alpha-IFN found in some studies is significant and, if so, the extent of this advantage.
在医学研究委员会(MRC)的试验中,采用ABCM(阿霉素、卡氮芥、环磷酰胺和美法仑)方案治疗的所有新诊断的多发性骨髓瘤患者中,64%达到了平台期;疾病的这一稳定临床阶段仅伴有极轻微的症状。多项研究发现,α-干扰素(α-IFN)维持治疗可延长平台期的持续时间,但这是否能转化为延长生存期尚不太明确。我们报告了在一项试验中α-IFN对平台期持续时间和总生存期的影响,该试验有284例患者,在首个平台期随机接受α2b-IFN(安进公司生产的重组人α2b干扰素)或不接受维持治疗。随机分组后的最短随访时间为21个月。两个治疗组的总生存期无显著差异(X2 = 0.32,P = 0.57)。接受α-IFN治疗的患者无复发生存期有延长的趋势,但这种平台期延长的趋势无统计学意义(X2 = 1.62,P = 0.2)。接受α-IFN治疗复发时疾病进展似乎更严重,血清副蛋白(P = 0.06)和β2-微球蛋白(P = 0.03)水平较平台期水平升高得更多。当患者接受α-IFN治疗时,医生倾向于在诊断复发后更快开始化疗(P = 0.16)。尽管与大多数其他研究一样,接受α-IFN治疗的患者有平台期延长的趋势,但这被治疗导致的发病率以及复发后生存期有所缩短所抵消。需要对干扰素试验进行荟萃分析,以评估在一些研究中发现的接受α-IFN维持治疗的患者生存期有轻微延长的趋势是否显著,以及若显著,这种优势的程度如何。