Stecker M M, Kramer T H, Raps E C, O'Meeghan R, Dulaney E, Skaar D J
Department of Neurology, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia 19104, USA.
Epilepsia. 1998 Jan;39(1):18-26. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.1998.tb01269.x.
We compared propofol with high-dose barbiturates in the treatment of refractory status epilepticus (RSE) and propose a protocol for the administration of propofol in RSE in adults, correlating propofol's effect with plasma levels.
Sixteen patients with RSE were included; 8 were treated primarily with high-dose barbiturates and 8 were treated primarily with propofol.
Both groups of patients had multiple medical problems and a subsequent high mortality. A smaller but not statistically significant fraction of patients had their seizures controlled with propofol (63%) than with high-dose barbiturate therapy (82%). The time from initiation of high-dose barbiturate therapy to attainment of control of RSE was longer (123 min) than the time to attainment of seizure control in the group receiving propofol (2.6 min, p = 0.002). Plasma concentrations of propofol associated with control of SE were 14 microM +/- 4 (2.5 microg/ml). Recurrent seizures were common when propofol infusions were suddenly discontinued but not when the infusions were gradually tapered.
If used appropriately, propofol infusions can effectively and quickly terminate many but not all episodes of RSE. Propofol is a promising agent for use in treating RSE, but more studies are required to determine its true value in comparison with other agents.
我们比较了丙泊酚与大剂量巴比妥类药物治疗难治性癫痫持续状态(RSE)的效果,并提出了成人RSE患者丙泊酚给药方案,将丙泊酚的疗效与血浆水平相关联。
纳入16例RSE患者;8例主要接受大剂量巴比妥类药物治疗,8例主要接受丙泊酚治疗。
两组患者均存在多种医疗问题,随后死亡率较高。与大剂量巴比妥类药物治疗(82%)相比,用丙泊酚控制癫痫发作的患者比例较小,但无统计学差异(63%)。从开始大剂量巴比妥类药物治疗到控制RSE的时间(123分钟)比接受丙泊酚治疗组达到癫痫控制的时间(2.6分钟,p = 0.002)更长。与SE控制相关的丙泊酚血浆浓度为14 microM +/- 4(2.5微克/毫升)。突然停止丙泊酚输注时癫痫复发很常见,但逐渐减少输注时则不然。
如果使用得当,丙泊酚输注可有效快速终止许多但并非所有RSE发作。丙泊酚是治疗RSE的一种有前景的药物,但需要更多研究来确定其与其他药物相比的真正价值。