Escaf Barmadah S, Martín Benito J L, Fernández Gómez J M, San Martín Blanco A, Pérez Gracia F J, Rodríguez Martínez J J
Departamento de Cirugía y Especialidades Médico Quirúrgico, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad de Oviedo, Asturias, España.
Arch Esp Urol. 1998 Mar;51(2):129-36.
To compare the usefulness and accuracy of the BTA test versus urinary cytology.
The BTA test was performed in 45 patients distributed into three groups: group I comprised patients with hematuria of unknown origin; group II had a diagnosis of bladder cancer; and group III comprised patients who had undergone TUR for a bladder tumor and were undergoing endoscopic control evaluation. The sensitivity and specificity of each diagnostic method were determined for each group of patients.
The BTA test showed a higher sensitivity than urinary cytology in all groups, the difference being significant for groups II and III. Its specificity, however, was lower than that of cytology in groups I and III, and similar in group II.
The BTA test is a simple and useful method for the diagnosis and follow-up of bladder cancer. It has a higher sensitivity than urinary cytology, although its specificity is lower due to the higher number of false positives observed in patients with inflammatory bladder conditions. Randomized studies are warranted to determine if the accuracy of urinary cytology can be enhanced with the combined use of the BTA test which has been demonstrated to have a higher specificity.
比较膀胱肿瘤抗原(BTA)检测与尿细胞学检查的有效性和准确性。
对45例患者进行BTA检测,这些患者分为三组:第一组为不明原因血尿患者;第二组已诊断为膀胱癌;第三组为因膀胱肿瘤接受经尿道切除术(TUR)且正在接受内镜控制评估的患者。针对每组患者确定每种诊断方法的敏感性和特异性。
BTA检测在所有组中的敏感性均高于尿细胞学检查,在第二组和第三组中差异显著。然而,其特异性在第一组和第三组中低于细胞学检查,在第二组中与之相似。
BTA检测是一种用于膀胱癌诊断和随访的简单且有用的方法。它比尿细胞学检查具有更高的敏感性,尽管由于在膀胱炎症患者中观察到较高的假阳性率,其特异性较低。有必要进行随机研究以确定联合使用已证明具有更高特异性的BTA检测是否能提高尿细胞学检查的准确性。