Freudenberg N, Wilets I, Greene M B, Richie B E
Hunter College Center on AIDS, Drugs and Community Health, New York City, USA.
J Am Med Womens Assoc (1972). 1998 Spring;53(2):89-93.
Women in jail experience high rates of many health and social problems. This study examined the effects of preexisting social and health characteristics and the type of services received on retention in community aftercare for 193 drug-using women released from the New York City jail to two low-income communities. Rearrest rates for program participants were compared to a group of women not eligible for services because of their residence outside the target communities. Women who enrolled in residential programs with on-site drug treatment and other social services after release were compared to women who enrolled in less comprehensive services. The residential treatment group participated in the program significantly longer (276 v 180 days, p = .02) than women in other types of services. Women in residential programs were significantly more likely to have used crack or cocaine in the 30 days prior to arrest than women in other types of programs (84% v 59%, p = .001), but few other prior differences among the different treatment groups were noted. Therefore, differences in outcome are unlikely to be attributed to preexisting differences in risk profile. Women who participated in postrelease services were significantly less likely to be rearrested in the year after release than a comparable group of women who participated in jail services, but were not eligible for postrelease services (38% v 59%, p = .02).
监狱中的女性面临着诸多健康和社会问题。本研究调查了193名从纽约市监狱释放到两个低收入社区的吸毒女性的既有社会和健康特征以及所接受服务的类型对社区后续照护留存率的影响。将项目参与者的再次逮捕率与因居住在目标社区之外而无资格获得服务的一组女性进行了比较。将释放后参加有现场戒毒治疗和其他社会服务的住院项目的女性与参加服务较不全面的女性进行了比较。住院治疗组参与项目的时间(276天对180天,p = 0.02)明显长于其他类型服务的女性。住院项目中的女性在被捕前30天内使用快克或可卡因的可能性明显高于其他类型项目中的女性(84%对59%,p = 0.001),但不同治疗组之间几乎没有其他先前差异。因此,结果的差异不太可能归因于风险状况的既有差异。与一组参与监狱服务但无资格获得释放后服务的可比女性相比,参与释放后服务的女性在释放后一年内再次被捕的可能性明显较低(38%对59%,p = 0.02)。