Comparative study of diagnostic measures in borderline surgical cases of unilateral cleft lip and palate and noncleft Class III malocclusions.

Patients with complete unilateral cleft lip and palate present difficult growth problems. Their anteroposterior discrepancies in jaw and dentition are frequently so severe that some epidemiologic studies report the necessity of orthognathic surgery in 25% of their sample. The aims of this study were three-fold: (1) to delineate diagnostic measures in borderline surgical cases of unilateral cleft lip and palate, (2) to verify the significance of negative overjet as a measure of anteroposterior discrepancy, and (3) to compare these diagnostic measures with those of borderline surgical cases of noncleft Class III malocclusions. The sample consisted of 29 patients with unilateral cleft lip and palate and 25 noncleft Class III Korean patients (mean age, 18.69 years); all had crossbites of all four incisors. Each of their pretreatment study casts and cephalograms were analyzed. The group with unilateral cleft lip and palate was divided into two subgroups on the basis of the method of their anterior crossbite resolution; 18 subjects were treated with orthodontics alone (Cleft-NS) and 11 subjects with orthognathic surgery (Cleft-Surg). The noncleft Class III group was divided into two subgroups; 6 of the subjects were orthodontically treated (Cl III-NS), and 19 were surgically treated (Cl III-Surg). The group with unilateral cleft lip and palate showed smaller SNA and SNB angles than the noncleft Class III group, but the ANB angles and the amount of anterior crossbites showed no statistical differences. When the Cleft-NS and the Cleft-Surg groups were compared, the ANB angle and the Wits measurements were significantly different. When the Cl III-NS and Cl III-Surg groups were compared, the SNB, ANB, L1GoGn, Wits, and the crossbite showed significant differences. For borderline surgical Class III unilateral cleft lip and palate cases, ANB angle, Wits appraisal, and ABGoGn angle were critical diagnostic parameters. On the other hand, the magnitude of anterior crossbite, the negative overjet, was shown not to be a significant measure of anteroposterior discrepancy.