Osler M, Heitmann B L
Department of Social Medicine and Psychosocial Health, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 1998 Mar;52(3):161-5. doi: 10.1136/jech.52.3.161.
Deficiencies in calcium and vitamin D intakes are involved in the aetiology of osteoporosis, and health authorities recommend that the population consume a diet providing sufficient calcium and vitamin D. However, in 1987 the Danish Government withdrew a mandatory fortification of flour with calcium. This study examines intakes of calcium and vitamin D over time, in relation to food patterns, recommendations, and legislation.
Food and nutrient intakes were measured by a short food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) and a thorough diet history interview, in 1987/88, and again six years later.
Copenhagen County, Denmark.
329 men and women, aged 35-65 years at first examination in 1987/88.
At both examinations the non-enriched median intakes of calcium in men as well as women were above the recommended 600 mg/day. However, apparently the fortification of flour supplied up to 30% of the total calcium intake, and without the mandatory fortification, the percentage of adults with intakes below this recommendation increased from 6% to 22%. This group of subjects consumed cheese, milk, and oatmeal less often than those who had calcium intakes over 600 mg/day. During the study period the median intakes of vitamin D, which were well below the recommended 5 micrograms/day, did not change significantly. Associations between foods and vitamin D intakes were, in general, weak and insignificant, except for a positive association with fish intake.
Data on calcium intakes suggest that the decision to stop the mandatory fortification of flour with calcium may have been premature. The short FFQ may be used for a rough classification of people in relation to their calcium intake, while this method seems insufficient for ranking vitamin D intakes.
钙和维生素D摄入不足与骨质疏松症的病因有关,卫生当局建议人们通过饮食摄入足够的钙和维生素D。然而,1987年丹麦政府取消了面粉中钙的强制强化。本研究调查了随着时间推移,钙和维生素D的摄入量与食物模式、建议及立法之间的关系。
1987/1988年通过简短食物频率问卷(FFQ)和详细饮食史访谈测量食物和营养素摄入量,并在六年后再次测量。
丹麦哥本哈根郡
1987/1988年首次检查时年龄在35 - 65岁之间的329名男性和女性。
在两次检查中,男性和女性未强化的钙摄入量中位数均高于建议的每日600毫克。然而,显然面粉强化提供了高达总钙摄入量的30%,如果没有强制强化,钙摄入量低于该建议值的成年人比例从6%增加到了22%。与钙摄入量超过600毫克/天的人群相比,这组受试者较少食用奶酪、牛奶和燕麦片。在研究期间,维生素D的摄入量中位数远低于建议的每日5微克,且没有显著变化。一般来说,食物与维生素D摄入量之间的关联较弱且无统计学意义,除了与鱼类摄入量呈正相关。
钙摄入量数据表明,停止面粉中钙的强制强化这一决定可能为时过早。简短的食物频率问卷可用于对人群的钙摄入量进行大致分类,但该方法似乎不足以对维生素D摄入量进行排名。