Farley T M, Collins J, Schlesselman J J
UN Development Programme/UN Population Fund/World Health Organization/ World Bank Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human Reproduction, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Contraception. 1998 Mar;57(3):211-30. doi: 10.1016/s0010-7824(98)00019-5.
The most frequent major adverse effect of hormonal contraception is an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. The effect on the risk of venous thromboembolism (VTE), ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke, and myocardial infarction (MI) differs and is strongly influenced by smoking and the presence of other cardiovascular risks factors, such as hypertension and diabetes mellitus. The incidence of each disease rises with age and there are differences in risk among hormonal contraceptive preparations. This article provides a framework within which to assess the balance of risks among types of hormonal contraceptives according to individual circumstances. Data on cardiovascular disease mortality rates in women of reproductive age in different countries of the world were compiled from nationally reported statistics and supplemented where possible with reported disease incidence rates. Risks associated with current use of hormonal contraception were compiled from the most recent publications on the cardiovascular effects of steroid hormone contraception. These were combined to estimate the total cardiovascular incidence and mortality according to baseline cardiovascular risk and individual characteristics. Mortality rates for cardiovascular diseases are very low in women of reproductive age. Myocardial infarction mortality rates rise from < 0.4 per 100,000 woman-years at age 15-24 years to the range 2 to 7 per 100,000 woman-years at age 35-44 years. Stroke mortality rates similarly rise steeply with age and are between 3 and 5 times higher than those for MI. VTE mortality rates rise less steeply with age and are approximately one-tenth the MI mortality rates at age 35-44 years. The adverse effect of oral contraceptives (OC) on the risk of VTE is the most important contributor to the total number of cardiovascular cases attributable to OC use. The increased risk of stroke and MI dominate the patterns of mortality in OC users and smokers. The additional risks attributable to smoking are greater than the additional risks attributable to OC use. The risk attributable to OC use in women < 35 years of age is small, even if they smoke, but there are substantially increased risks in older women who both smoke and use OC. The additional mortality attributable to OC use can be reduced by screening users, as this results in lower relative risks of ischemic stroke and MI. Differences between OC types in the relative risk of VTE contribute little to the total cardiovascular mortality associated with OC use, even though the total number of cardiovascular events is increased. A potential reduction in the risk of MI with desogestrel and gestodene compared with levonorgestrel-containing OC would have little difference on overall mortality rates in women in their 20s and 30s, but may result in a net reduction in OC-attributable mortality in women aged 40-44 years who smoke. An overall quantification of the risks for different types of oral contraceptive users is necessary for an informed choice of contraceptive method, and any assessment of the balance of cardiovascular risks is complex. The model provides a tool to assess, at the level of the individual, the risks associated with use of different OC according to personal circumstances. It is important to consider the user's age and smoking status when determining OC attributable risks.
激素避孕最常见的主要不良反应是心血管疾病风险增加。其对静脉血栓栓塞(VTE)、缺血性和出血性中风以及心肌梗死(MI)风险的影响有所不同,且受到吸烟以及其他心血管危险因素(如高血压和糖尿病)的强烈影响。每种疾病的发病率都随年龄增长而上升,不同激素避孕制剂的风险也存在差异。本文提供了一个框架,可据此根据个体情况评估不同类型激素避孕药之间的风险平衡。世界不同国家育龄女性心血管疾病死亡率的数据是根据各国上报的统计数据汇编而成的,并在可能的情况下补充了上报的疾病发病率数据。与当前使用激素避孕相关的风险是从关于甾体激素避孕心血管影响的最新出版物中汇编而来的。将这些数据结合起来,根据基线心血管风险和个体特征估算总的心血管发病率和死亡率。育龄女性心血管疾病的死亡率非常低。心肌梗死死亡率从15 - 24岁时每10万女性年<0.4例升至35 - 44岁时每10万女性年2至7例的范围。中风死亡率同样随年龄急剧上升,比心肌梗死死亡率高3至5倍。VTE死亡率随年龄上升幅度较小,在35 - 44岁时约为心肌梗死死亡率的十分之一。口服避孕药(OC)对VTE风险的不良影响是OC使用所致心血管病例总数的最重要因素。中风和心肌梗死风险的增加主导了OC使用者和吸烟者的死亡模式。吸烟所致的额外风险大于OC使用所致的额外风险。35岁以下女性使用OC所致的风险较小,即使她们吸烟,但在吸烟且使用OC的老年女性中风险大幅增加。通过筛查使用者可降低OC使用所致的额外死亡率,因为这会降低缺血性中风和心肌梗死的相对风险。尽管心血管事件总数增加,但不同OC类型在VTE相对风险方面的差异对与OC使用相关的总心血管死亡率影响不大。与含左炔诺孕酮的OC相比,去氧孕烯和孕二烯酮可能降低心肌梗死风险,这对二三十岁女性的总体死亡率影响不大,但可能会使40 - 44岁吸烟女性中OC所致死亡率净降低。对于明智地选择避孕方法而言,对不同类型口服避孕药使用者的风险进行全面量化是必要的,而任何对心血管风险平衡的评估都很复杂。该模型提供了一种工具,可在个体层面根据个人情况评估使用不同OC的相关风险。在确定OC所致风险时,考虑使用者的年龄和吸烟状况很重要。