Yawn B P, Suman V J, Jacobsen S J
Department of Research, Olmsted Medical Center, Rochester, Minnesota 55904, USA.
J Clin Epidemiol. 1998 May;51(5):399-405. doi: 10.1016/s0895-4356(97)00304-1.
Women themselves are often the most convenient source of information regarding their pregnancy and birth outcomes such as prematurity. However, the ability of mothers to recall birth information and the accuracy of information they do recall has rarely been assessed. This study used a mail survey of women who delivered either term or preterm infants in Rochester, Minnesota, between 1980 and 1985. Maternal reports of circumstances and outcome of delivery were compared to data abstracted from the medical records. Maternal ability to recall and report events varied from 99.5% for smoking during pregnancy to 85% for infant's gestational age at birth. Agreement between medical record and maternal report was very high for perinatal events such as delivery by cesarean section, preexisting diabetes, and smoking. Percent negative agreement was quite high when comparing information on rare events such as placental abruption. Recall of gestational age was better for women delivering preterm infants but uncommon in all women. Maternal reports of perinatal events in which they directly participated such as cesarean section can be accurately and reliably reported 10 to 15 years after the birth. Gestational age is reported less accurately and with different rates of recall for mothers with term and preterm deliveries.
女性自身往往是有关其怀孕及分娩结局(如早产)的最便捷信息来源。然而,母亲回忆分娩信息的能力以及她们所回忆信息的准确性很少得到评估。本研究对1980年至1985年间在明尼苏达州罗切斯特市分娩足月或早产婴儿的女性进行了邮件调查。将母亲对分娩情况和结局的报告与从病历中提取的数据进行了比较。母亲回忆和报告事件的能力从孕期吸烟的99.5%到婴儿出生时的胎龄的85%不等。对于剖宫产、孕前糖尿病和吸烟等围产期事件,病历与母亲报告之间的一致性非常高。在比较胎盘早剥等罕见事件的信息时,阴性一致率相当高。早产产妇对胎龄的回忆较好,但在所有女性中都不常见。母亲对她们直接参与的围产期事件(如剖宫产)的报告在分娩后10至15年可以准确可靠地给出。对于足月和早产产妇,胎龄的报告准确性较低,且回忆率不同。