Ford C D, Reilly W, Wood J, Classen D C, Burke J P
Department of Medicine, LDS Hospital, Salt Lake City, Utah 84143, USA.
Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1998 Jun;42(6):1402-5. doi: 10.1128/AAC.42.6.1402.
The optimal oral antimicrobial prophylactic regimen for bone marrow transplant recipients remains to be elucidated. We randomized 84 patients to receive either oral ciprofloxacin or ciprofloxacin plus vancomycin at hospital admission. Patients were monitored for bacteremias and clinical parameters, and stool and throat swab surveillance cultures were performed. The addition of vancomycin resulted in a significant decrease in the frequency of patients with surveillance cultures positive for coagulase-negative staphylococci (stool cultures, 44 versus 23%; throat swab cultures, 37 versus 19%) and alpha-hemolytic streptococci (throat swab cultures, 90 versus 60%). The frequencies of positivity for Candida spp. and gram-negative organisms on surveillance cultures were comparable. Despite these results, no differences in the incidences of bacteremias (12 of 41 versus 12 of 43 patients) or clinical parameters such as number of days to first fever, total number of febrile days, length of stay, and number of transfusions could be demonstrated. Because of a lack of efficacy of vancomycin and emerging problems with vancomycin-resistant isolates, vancomycin should not be used in oral antimicrobial prophylaxis regimens.
骨髓移植受者的最佳口服抗菌预防方案仍有待阐明。我们将84例患者随机分组,在入院时分别给予口服环丙沙星或环丙沙星加万古霉素。对患者进行菌血症和临床参数监测,并进行粪便和咽拭子监测培养。加用万古霉素后,凝固酶阴性葡萄球菌监测培养阳性患者的频率显著降低(粪便培养,44%对23%;咽拭子培养,37%对19%),α溶血性链球菌监测培养阳性患者的频率也显著降低(咽拭子培养,90%对60%)。念珠菌属和革兰阴性菌监测培养的阳性频率相当。尽管有这些结果,但在菌血症发生率(41例患者中的12例对43例患者中的12例)或临床参数如首次发热天数、发热总天数、住院时间和输血次数方面未显示出差异。由于万古霉素缺乏疗效以及耐万古霉素菌株出现的新问题,万古霉素不应在口服抗菌预防方案中使用。