Tramontin A D, Smith G T, Breuner C W, Brenowitz E A
Department of Zoology, University of Washington, Seattle 98195, USA.
J Comp Neurol. 1998 Jun 29;396(2):186-92. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1096-9861(19980629)396:2<186::aid-cne4>3.0.co;2-x.
Differences in neuron density and number are associated with seasonal plasticity and sexual dimorphism in the avian song control system. In previous studies, neuron density and number in this system have been quantified primarily through nonstereological approaches in thick tissue sections by using the nucleolus as the unit of count. The reported differences between seasons and sexes may be inaccurate due to biases introduced by neuron splitting during sectioning. We used the unbiased optical disector technique on tissue from three previous studies (two investigations of seasonal plasticity and one investigation of sexual dimorphism in avian song nuclei) to assess seasonal and sex differences in neuron density and number. In two song nuclei, HVc and the robust nucleus of the archistriatum (RA), the optical disector yielded intergroup differences in neuron density and number that coincided well with the three previous reports. We also estimated neuron number and density with a random, systematic, nonstereological counting protocol that used the neuronal nucleolus as the unit of count. We compared this method directly to the optical disector. In all cases, the two neuron-counting methods produced similar estimates of neuron number and density; the differences between treatment groups were equally discernible regardless of the counting method used. This study confirms previously reported seasonal and sex differences in the HVc and the RA by use of stereology and indicates that a random, systematic, nonstereological neuron-counting protocol is accurate and is well suited to the study of these phenomena in the avian song control system.
神经元密度和数量的差异与鸟类鸣叫控制系统中的季节性可塑性和两性异形有关。在先前的研究中,该系统中的神经元密度和数量主要是通过在厚组织切片中使用核仁作为计数单位的非立体学方法进行量化的。由于切片过程中神经元分裂所引入的偏差,所报道的季节和性别之间的差异可能不准确。我们对之前三项研究(两项关于季节性可塑性的调查和一项关于鸟类鸣叫核团两性异形的调查)中的组织使用了无偏倚光学分割技术,以评估神经元密度和数量的季节和性别差异。在两个鸣叫核团,即HVC和古纹状体粗核(RA)中,光学分割技术得出的神经元密度和数量的组间差异与之前的三项报告非常吻合。我们还使用了一种以神经元核仁作为计数单位的随机、系统的非立体学计数方案来估计神经元数量和密度。我们将这种方法与光学分割技术直接进行了比较。在所有情况下,两种神经元计数方法对神经元数量和密度的估计相似;无论使用哪种计数方法,治疗组之间的差异都同样明显。本研究通过使用体视学方法证实了先前报道的HVC和RA中的季节和性别差异,并表明一种随机、系统的非立体学神经元计数方案是准确的,并且非常适合于研究鸟类鸣叫控制系统中的这些现象。