Dubois C, Dufour P, Quandalle F, Lanvin D, Levasseur M, Monnier J C
Hôpital Jeanne de Flandre, CHRU de Lille.
Contracept Fertil Sex. 1998 May;26(5):363-71.
BUT: Try to precise the optimal management in 1997 face a breech presentation.
Between January 1991 and December 1995, 304 cases of breech presentations were listed at the maternity of Pavillon Victor Olivier (Lille). From these 304 breech presentations, all parities blended, the authors have analysed the mode of delivery of these patients, distinguishing the para one from the multiparous women and the preterm babies from the other babies. From this study and a review of the literature, were discussed the criterions which can help the practitioner to determine the mode of delivery of these fetus.
The results show a cesarean section (cs) rate of 51% (41% of first intention cs and 10% of second intention cs were realized only for primiparity + breech presentation and 67% of the para one women benefited from a first intention cs 8.72% of vaginal deliveries were complicated, and 5 fetal injuries were noted without sequel. On 296 live new-borns, only 2 cases of fetal death were perhaps due to the vaginal delivery. Fetal mortality is principally reliable at the prematurity and the congenital malformations, but finally, not due to mode of delivery.
The difficulty is to determine rigorous criterions of selection to authorize a vaginal delivery without spoil the fetal pronostic. The major criterions are a perfect radiopelvimetry, an estimated fetal weight < 3800 g for the para one women and < 4300 g for the multiparous woman, a well flexed fetal head, favorable obstetric conditions ond the absence of maternal or fetal complications. The primiparity is not an indication of systematic cesariean section.
但是:尝试明确1997年面对臀位分娩时的最佳处理方法。
1991年1月至1995年12月期间,在里尔的维克多·奥利维尔大楼产科登记了304例臀位分娩病例。在这304例臀位分娩病例中,作者分析了所有产妇(不论胎次)的分娩方式,区分了初产妇与经产妇以及早产婴儿与其他婴儿。通过这项研究以及文献综述,讨论了有助于从业者确定这些胎儿分娩方式的标准。
结果显示剖宫产率为51%(其中仅因初产妇 + 臀位分娩而实施的一期剖宫产率为41%,二期剖宫产率为10%),67%的初产妇接受了一期剖宫产。8.72%的阴道分娩出现并发症,记录到5例胎儿损伤但无后遗症。在296例活产新生儿中,仅2例胎儿死亡可能归因于阴道分娩。胎儿死亡率主要与早产和先天性畸形有关,但最终并非由于分娩方式所致。
难点在于确定严格的选择标准以准许阴道分娩而不影响胎儿预后。主要标准包括完善的骨盆测量、初产妇估计胎儿体重 < 3800 g,经产妇 < 4300 g,胎儿头部良好屈曲、有利的产科条件以及无母体或胎儿并发症。初产并非系统性剖宫产的指征。