Suppr超能文献

还原论与反还原论。

Reductionism and antireductionism.

作者信息

Nagel T

机构信息

New York University Law School, NY 10012, USA.

出版信息

Novartis Found Symp. 1998;213:3-10; discussion 10-4, 73-5.

PMID:9653712
Abstract

Reductionism is the idea that all of the complex and apparently disparate things we observe in the world can be explained in terms of universal principles governing their common ultimate constituents: that physics is the theory of everything. Antireductionism comes in two varieties: epistemological and ontological. Epistemological antireductionism holds that, given our finite mental capacities, we would not be able to grasp the ultimate physical explantation of many complex phenomena even if we knew the laws governing their ultimate constituents. Therefore we will always need special sciences like biology, which use more manageable descriptions. There may be controversy about which special sciences cannot be replaced by reduction, but that there will be some is uncontroversial. Ontological antireductionism holds, much more controversially, that certain higher-order phenomena cannot even in principle be fully explained by physics, but require additional principles that are not entailed by the laws governing the basic constituents. With respect to biology, the question is whether the existence and operation of highly complex functionally organized systems, and the appearance of self-replicating systems in the universe, can be accounted for in terms of particle physics alone, or whether they require independent principles of order.

摘要

还原论是这样一种观点,即我们在世界上观察到的所有复杂且看似不同的事物都可以依据支配其共同基本组成部分的普遍原理来解释:也就是说物理学是万物理论。反还原论有两种类型:认识论的和本体论的。认识论反还原论认为,鉴于我们有限的心智能力,即便我们知晓支配其基本组成部分的定律,我们也无法理解许多复杂现象的最终物理解释。因此,我们将始终需要诸如生物学这样的特殊科学,它们使用更易于处理的描述。对于哪些特殊科学不能被还原所取代可能存在争议,但存在一些不可被还原的特殊科学这一点是毫无争议的。本体论反还原论则持有一种更具争议性的观点,即某些高阶现象甚至在原则上都无法完全由物理学来解释,而是需要一些并非由支配基本组成部分的定律所蕴含的额外原理。就生物学而言,问题在于高度复杂的功能组织系统的存在与运作,以及宇宙中自我复制系统的出现,能否仅依据粒子物理学来解释,或者它们是否需要独立的秩序原理。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验