Melbye H
Institutt for Samfunnsmedisin, Universitetet i Tromsø.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1998 May 20;118(13):1999-2003.
In order to evaluate the usefulness of physical examination of the chest in diagnosing bronchial obstruction, 11 doctors recorded their findings in 692 adult chest patients. Spirometry was carried out after the physical examination. Two categories of patients were selected; patients with known or suspected pulmonary disease (n = 209) and patients who had consulted their doctors for other reasons (n = 483). Bronchial obstruction defined as either FEV1 < 70% predicted or FEV1 < 70% of FVC, was found in 74 of the "pulmonary patients" and 55 of the "non-pulmonary" patients. In the group of patients with bronchial obstruction, a pathological or less certain sign of chest disorder was found in 91% of the "pulmonary" patients, and in 42% of the "non-pulmonary" patients (p < 0.000001). Strenuous respiration was registered in 41% of the "pulmonary" patients with bronchial obstruction, whereas sensitivity was only 2% in the other group. Where there were two or more pathological chest findings, the risk of bronchial obstruction occurring was 66% among the "pulmonary" patients, as opposed to 37% in the "non-pulmonary" group. Physical examination of the chest appeared to be very useful in the detection of bronchial obstruction in patients with pulmonary symptoms, but of limited value in screening for bronchial obstruction.
为了评估胸部体格检查在诊断支气管阻塞方面的效用,11位医生记录了他们对692名成年胸部疾病患者的检查结果。体格检查后进行了肺功能测定。选取了两类患者:已知或疑似患有肺部疾病的患者(n = 209)以及因其他原因就医的患者(n = 483)。在“肺部疾病患者”中有74例、“非肺部疾病患者”中有55例被诊断为支气管阻塞,其定义为第一秒用力呼气容积(FEV1)<预测值的70%或FEV1<用力肺活量(FVC)的70%。在支气管阻塞患者组中,91%的“肺部疾病”患者以及42%的“非肺部疾病”患者发现有胸部疾病的病理性体征或不太确定的体征(p < 0.000001)。41%的患有支气管阻塞的“肺部疾病”患者记录到呼吸急促,而另一组的敏感度仅为2%。在有两项或更多病理性胸部检查结果的情况下,“肺部疾病”患者中发生支气管阻塞的风险为66%,而“非肺部疾病”组为37%。胸部体格检查在检测有肺部症状患者的支气管阻塞方面似乎非常有用,但在筛查支气管阻塞方面价值有限。