Rhoades E R, Frank A A, Orme I M
Department of Microbiology, Colorado State University, USA.
Tuber Lung Dis. 1997;78(1):57-66. doi: 10.1016/s0962-8479(97)90016-2.
There are several critical differences in the pulmonary granulomatous response to Mycobacterium tuberculosis between the mouse and other animal models such as the guinea pig or rabbit. One key difference is a conspicuous lack of central caseating necrosis in pulmonary lesions of immunologically intact mice. To determine whether normal mice could develop such pathology in response to highly virulent clinical isolates of M. tuberculosis, C57BL/6 mice were infected aerogenically with varying doses of three different strains, and the development of a granulomatous response was followed for as long as a year. Whereas such conditions failed to induce caseating necrosis in the lungs of these mice, all of the infections induced a granulomatous response which progressed similarly. We present here a descriptive report of the gross pathological progression of tuberculosis in the lungs of the mice. In each case, the disease progressed in five discrete stages, which were delineated on the basis of several criteria including the extent of granulomatous involvement, the cell types present, the degree of lymphocyte organization, and the presence of destructive sequelae such as airway epithelium erosion and airway debris. Quicker progression of disease along these five stages was induced by increasing the size of the inoculum or by the more virulent mycobacterial strains. The infections with the virulent strains were not resolved, and the later stages of the granulomatous response coincided with an increasing bacillary load and a loss of organized lymphocytes in the infected lungs which ultimately resulted in the death of the host. These results indicate that although C57BL/6 mice do not manifest a caseating form of pulmonary tuberculosis, they manifest an equally pathogenic granulomatous response which appears as a chronic interstitial fibrosing response that fails to contain the infection at a time that organized lymphocyte involvement wanes in the lung.
在小鼠与其他动物模型(如豚鼠或兔子)对结核分枝杆菌的肺部肉芽肿反应中,存在几个关键差异。一个关键差异是免疫健全小鼠的肺部病变明显缺乏中央干酪样坏死。为了确定正常小鼠对高毒力结核分枝杆菌临床分离株是否会产生这种病理变化,将不同剂量的三种不同菌株经气溶胶感染C57BL/6小鼠,并对肉芽肿反应的发展进行长达一年的跟踪观察。尽管这些条件未能在这些小鼠的肺部诱导干酪样坏死,但所有感染均诱导了肉芽肿反应,且其进展相似。我们在此呈现小鼠肺部结核病大体病理进展的描述性报告。在每种情况下,疾病进展分为五个不同阶段,这些阶段是根据几个标准划分的,包括肉芽肿累及范围、存在的细胞类型、淋巴细胞组织程度以及是否存在气道上皮侵蚀和气道碎屑等破坏性后遗症。通过增加接种量或使用毒力更强的分枝杆菌菌株,可使疾病在这五个阶段更快进展。毒力菌株感染未得到解决,肉芽肿反应的后期阶段与感染肺部细菌载量增加和有组织的淋巴细胞丢失同时出现,最终导致宿主死亡。这些结果表明,尽管C57BL/6小鼠未表现出干酪样肺结核形式,但它们表现出同样具有致病性的肉芽肿反应,这种反应表现为慢性间质性纤维化反应,在肺部有组织的淋巴细胞参与减少时无法控制感染。