Lindsay W R, Marshall I, Neilson C, Quinn K, Smith A H
University of Abertay, Dundee, Scotland.
Res Dev Disabil. 1998 Jul-Aug;19(4):295-316. doi: 10.1016/s0891-4222(98)00010-9.
This paper reviews work on the treatment of men convicted of exhibitionism or indecent exposure. Recidivism is extremely high after treatments, with true figures on recidivism unavailable until 4 years after conviction. It is extremely difficult to control for treatment effects because of the ethical issues surrounding withholding of treatment, but cognitive techniques provide a promising treatment approach. The present study attempted to address all these issues for men with a learning disability. A cognitive treatment is presented and data are available for at least 5 years after conviction. An AB design was used and treatment effects were monitored carefully. Treatment dealt with the issues of accepting that the offense took place, taking responsibility for the offense, accepting the intention of the offending behavior, victim awareness, and behavior consistent with offending for four offenders. All the men responded to treatment, although one offender with only 1 year of probation responded less convincingly than others. Beliefs relating to indecent exposure being fun or not causing harm to women seemed most open to alteration. The beliefs in which the perpetrator thought that the victim shared responsibility for the offense and that women may take a long while to recover from such an incident, seemed the most difficult to alter. Individual characteristics of the case examples are discussed in terms of these general trends.
本文回顾了对被判露阴癖或猥亵暴露罪男性的治疗工作。治疗后的累犯率极高,在定罪后4年内都无法获得真实的累犯数据。由于围绕不给予治疗的伦理问题,很难控制治疗效果,但认知技术提供了一种有前景的治疗方法。本研究试图解决有学习障碍男性的所有这些问题。提出了一种认知治疗方法,并且在定罪后至少5年都有数据可用。采用了AB设计,并仔细监测了治疗效果。治疗针对四名罪犯处理了以下问题:接受犯罪行为的发生、为犯罪行为负责、接受冒犯行为的意图、受害者意识以及与犯罪行为一致的行为。所有男性都对治疗有反应,尽管一名只有1年缓刑期的罪犯反应不如其他人有说服力。与露阴行为有趣或不会对女性造成伤害相关的信念似乎最容易改变。犯罪者认为受害者对犯罪行为负有责任以及女性可能需要很长时间才能从这类事件中恢复的信念,似乎最难改变。根据这些总体趋势讨论了案例的个体特征。