Hunt C, Andrews G
University of New South Wales, St. Vincent's Hospital, Australia.
J Anxiety Disord. 1998 Jul-Aug;12(4):395-406. doi: 10.1016/s0887-6185(98)00023-1.
The question is addressed as to whether cognitive-behavior treatment delivered as a routine service in a specialist clinic is effective in the long term. Of 124 consecutive patients completing treatment for panic disorder or social phobia, 93 were assessed an average of 2 years following treatment. The treatment produced significant improvement in measures of symptoms, avoidance, and disablement during treatment and further significant improvement during the follow-up. A quarter of participants no longer met diagnostic criteria, had not sought further treatment, and their anxiety had not troubled them since treatment. These findings, although not showing the large treatment effects reported from controlled outcome research, support the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral interventions in routine care.
问题在于,在专科诊所作为常规服务提供的认知行为疗法从长期来看是否有效。在连续完成惊恐障碍或社交恐惧症治疗的124名患者中,93名患者在治疗后平均2年接受了评估。该治疗在治疗期间使症状、回避行为和功能障碍的测量指标有显著改善,在随访期间进一步显著改善。四分之一的参与者不再符合诊断标准,未寻求进一步治疗,且自治疗后焦虑不再困扰他们。这些发现虽然未显示出对照结果研究报告的巨大治疗效果,但支持了认知行为干预在常规护理中的有效性。