Ticho B S, Neufeld E J, Newburger J W, Harris N, Baker A, Rifai N
Department of Cardiology, Children's Hospital, Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass 02115, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998 Aug;152(8):787-91. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.152.8.787.
Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) levels are the primary basis for treatment guidelines established for hyperlipidemic children and adolescents. Levels of LDL-C are commonly monitored by means of the Friedewald formula, an indirect calculation that requires an overnight fast. A new method has been developed for the direct measurement of LDL-C (DLDL-C) that does not require fasting. We evaluated the clinical utility of this method.
We determined LDL-C concentrations simultaneously by the DLDL-C method, Friedewald equation, and beta-quantification (reference procedure).
Pediatric dyslipidemia clinic at Children's Hospital, Boston, Mass.
Ninety-two fasting hyperlipidemic pediatric patients.
At the LDL-C concentration cutoffs commonly used for making therapeutic decisions, the DLDL-C method had a significant negative bias (P< or =.05) and misclassified patients into incorrect treatment groups more often than the Friedewald method. The negative predictive value for the DLDL-C method was lower than that for the Friedewald method (P< or =.05), and the cost of determining LDL-C level with the new method was 3 times greater.
The misclassification potential for LDL-C, and the assay costs, were greater for the DLDL-C method than for the Friedewald calculation. Despite the apparent advantages of the DLDL-C method, we conclude that for hyperlipidemic children the utility of this new method is not advantageous over the conventional Friedewald method. In some conditions, such as in diabetes or marked hypertriglyceridemia, the DLDL-C method may be useful.
低密度脂蛋白胆固醇(LDL-C)水平是为高脂血症儿童和青少年制定的治疗指南的主要依据。LDL-C水平通常通过Friedewald公式进行监测,这是一种间接计算方法,需要隔夜禁食。已开发出一种无需禁食即可直接测量LDL-C(DLDL-C)的新方法。我们评估了该方法的临床实用性。
我们同时采用DLDL-C法、Friedewald方程和β定量法(参考方法)测定LDL-C浓度。
马萨诸塞州波士顿儿童医院的儿科血脂异常诊所。
92名空腹高脂血症儿科患者。
在常用于做出治疗决策的LDL-C浓度临界值时,DLDL-C法存在显著负偏差(P≤0.05),与Friedewald法相比,将患者错误分类到不正确治疗组的情况更常见。DLDL-C法的阴性预测值低于Friedewald法(P≤0.05),且用新方法测定LDL-C水平的成本高出3倍。
DLDL-C法对LDL-C的错误分类可能性和检测成本均高于Friedewald计算法。尽管DLDL-C法有明显优势,但我们得出结论,对于高脂血症儿童,这种新方法的实用性并不优于传统的Friedewald法。在某些情况下,如糖尿病或明显的高甘油三酯血症,DLDL-C法可能有用。